La Herradura Inc II

1323 North Ave, New Rochelle - 10804
76 reviews
Mexican
(914) 235-3769

I used to love coming here years ago despite the bad attitude from the female employees. Came back recently to find that they’ve gotten cheap with their food. Tacos barely have any meat and are made on 1 tortilla as opposed to 2 like they used to. Food is bland and under seasoned. Drinks are watered down and this includes shots. The guacamole is incredibly small for the price. Female employees still remain rude amidst the quality going down substantially. Will not be returning or recommending this restaurant. Over hyped by locals with no taste.

I used to love coming here years ago despite the bad attitude from the female employees. Came back recently to find that they’ve gotten cheap with their food. Tacos barely have any meat and are made on 1 tortilla as opposed to 2 like they used to. Food is bland and under seasoned. Drinks are watered down and this includes shots. The guacamole is incredibly small for the price. Female employees still remain rude amidst the quality going down substantially. Will not be returning or recommending this restaurant. Over hyped by locals with no taste.

As a fellow Latino it pains me to not support a fellow Spanish restaurant like this. The food was cheap they spent more time making a plate look presentable & stylish than on the food. The quality was horrible the quantity even worse. I thought I was going to a nice Spanish restaurant instead it was like going to a wannabe 5 star French restaurant or a restaurant with a 5 star chef. I STRONGLY do not recommend this place. You want good Mexican food? Go to the best HERRADURA restaurant located on Main Street. They do not disappoint. The food there is 100 times better. Only came here because that one was closed for the day thinking it would be the same experience. It wasn’t. Never coming here again. I’m sticking to the one on Main Street in new Rochelle. As should anyone else who wants good food with great quality & quantity.

Located on North ave :Not real Mexican food , everything taste cheap not authentic , definitely overpriced

Wonderful low key place in Wykagyl NY. Very authentic. I love the salsa that comes out with the nachos. The decor is a bit much... they should take the piñatas down because everything is on the tables and chairs. It looks better. The menu is nice you have so many choices. Vegans would love it here as well. Very laid back and very affordable.

The food was amazing and service was great. I came here with my family and I am definitely coming back.

I don't like to give negative reviews because I think business are doing the best to serve us but this time the food wasn't as I expected. Drinks are good though.Good place for drinks and snacks.

Had high hopes for it but was sadly disappointed. The food was bland and generic. Not what I was hoping after seeing that interestingly themed interior and exterior. Too bad because there aremt a lot of good Mexican restaurants left in the area.

Love this place. Food is so good and you really feel like you’re in a place in Mexico. The drinks are delicious.

Great food and service. I felt so welcomed and eating by myself, I really appreciated the hospitality.