4 Bros Pizza

23 S Division St, New Rochelle - 10805
89 reviews
Pizza Italian
(914) 355-5178

Asked for two slices well done… they put it in for 30 seconds after taking it from the counter. I asked them to put it back in because i like my pizza crispy. I got attitude so i said no thank you and walked out. They walked out to ask why I’m leaving and i explained I’m paying for the pizza the way i want it or nothing. LOL they told me don’t come back!!! Amazing customer service i told them god bless and proceeded to the next pizza shop and they had no problem giving me my pizza WELL done.

I picked up my order. Pizza was good. They didnt give me the marinara sauce I asked for, for my garlic knots. 3 star rating because some of the staff was rude starting from taking my phone order. They made me feel like they were doing me a favor by eating from there. One guy was awkwardly just looking at me not saying anything half the time.. Good pizza but i’m not going back.

Very friendly staff and amazing pizza! The crust is top tier, gotta try it!

My family and I are very impressed with four brothers pizza! We are pizza lovers and are obsessed with this place! The ingredients are very fresh and you can tell in the taste of the food! Also look out for their Instagram secret menu for the chicken parm sliders on garlic knots! AMAZINGGGG!!!

SO good! Everything from here has been incredible. Recently they had a vodka parm slider special and they were some of the best tasting things I’ve ever had. Also the caramalized Bianco pizza is to die for!!

Great pizza and I personally want to thank the wife for her warm kindness and hospitality and the Father who helped me restart my car when my battery died. Cheers and God bless??

I started visiting this establishment and was thrilled with their pizza , however as of late, the pizza is tasting terrible, there appears to be a lack of enthusiasm and pride in their product… what a shame

Amazing pizza in New rochelle. Please give them a try you will be grateful

We have been there few times. Good place for gourmet pizza .. They have unique topping option. You can buy regular pizza slices but exclusive topping gourmet what differentiate them in New Rochelle.

There is nothing on the menu that disappoints? everything is so flavorful and delicious!! Highly suggest the tangy bbq and volcano pizzas andd the rice dishes are the bomb