Yani's Pizza

202 North St, Middletown - 10940
56 reviews
Pizza Italian
(845) 239-4746

You MUST Try The Philly Cheesesteak!

Ordered through DoorDash came almost 2 hrs late and food was cold. Never received our soda and when store was called we were hung up on. Very unprofessional.

Ordered through DoorDash and order was almost 2 hrs late. Food was cold and never received soda. First we were told sorry it’s busy. Then it said order was delivered and it wasn’t. Once the order was delivered and we realized we never got the soda we called back. Whoever the man was that answered the phone was very rude and told us what would you like me to do give you money back then he hung up on us. Try to support small local businesses and this was our answer. Very disappointed and would never order again. $51 what a waste of money. I could have gotten McDonald’s faster and hotter. What a shame!!!!

Slice was okay. It is much better when it hot. By the time I got to eat it was a little cold. Would go back again.

The pizza is decent. I got the wings in their “yani sauce” and it is straight vile. I’ve never seen my wife make the face she did when I had her taste it. Loaded fries weren’t the best either. The wings tanked the review for me though. I feel ripped off for paying for them.

Very rude. Customer service is terrible. NASTY.

Very Good Pizza, Well Worth It.

I ordered food while I was at work on Monday 4/12. It took almost 2 hours to be delivered. I called after an hour and 20 mins and the guy said the driver was on their way. It finally gets to me and the curly cheese fries were cold and hard, the “fried flounder SUB” that I got to split with someone was on a hamburger roll with 1 square piece of whatever fish cut in half and soggy and the beef/cheese patties were hard around the edges like they were microwaved. I called to complain (which isn’t something I ever do) and the guy really gave ME an attitude and kept asking what I wanted to do so I said give me my money back I guess. He said no lol he ended up saying he could give me $15 back on my card (the total was $27.88). It is now Sunday 4/18, I just checked my bank account and they never even gave me the $15 back.

Ordered a chicken parm combo with fried oreos tonight. Placed the order well before 9:00 they close at 10:00 . I placed it through doordash. I called once said my order was on it's way. It is now 10:20 PM as I write this review and my order still hasn't arrived. If I could leave 0 stars I would. I would definitely be reporting this to doordash and also calling for a refund tomorrow once Yani's is opened .

My favorite pizza place hands down