MIX N MAC - Mac & Cheese

280 NY-211, Middletown - 10940
219 reviews
American Gluten-Free Comfort Food
(845) 381-5536

I honestly thought that no one could top my mom's homemade Mac and Cheese. Although it stood uncontested for almost 20 years, this place has made my mom's homemade Mac and Cheese look like a box of Kraft. This place is so good, I can't believe there is only one of these restaurants. The dishes are cooked to perfection, there is a beautiful bread crumb crust at the top, that makes a beautiful sound when you break into it. The cheese tastes super fresh, and it passes the stretch test. And the Mac and Cheese balls are PHENOMENAL; combine them with the sauce that they give you, and there are no words that can describe it's perfection. If they weren't 45 minutes away from me, I would eat there every single day.Overall, one of the best restaurants I've ever eaten at, and I would recommend this to anyone (or any family), that wants something super filling, and delicious. Great job, I will definitely be coming back in the future!

This place is absolutely amazing, the portions are good for 2 or 3 meals. had the lobster mac and cheese that had real lobster!! not that imitation nonsense at the Chinese place. will def be back

Always the greatest staff working. Everyone is very kind and friendly. Food is always delicious and so filling. So many great combos to have for everyone to try. Such a great place to get a different taste of Mac and cheese.

ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS!!! A meal in itself. Not salty, not greasy or oily, but just delightful on your palate. The pasta is cooked just right. Even the broccoli is fresh but cooked perfectly to retain firmness but soft enough to blend in with the consistency of the pasta. I would definitely recommend this place and visit again when in the area.

Yummy! If you love cheesy Mac. This is the place for you.

They have the BEST Mac n Cheese I've ever had in my life, and you can get any kind of Mac or you can create your own Mac n Cheese dish

I love this place. Mac and Cheese is great. Staff is sometime lacking.

Great idea.Great food.Massive selection.

I stop in every now and then. I like to describe them as something different. I've tried different flavors. Some I liked better than others. But I do like most of what I've had.They are not cheap for what it is, but not drastically expensive either. In my opinion, you should give them a try. You may like it more than you think.

Awesome burger Mac and cheese. The personal pan is amazing and I don’t know how you can not love all their flavors to be honest. I drive 30 minutes just to get this food. The only challenge is the wait times. Too long however it’s worth it.