If you from Middletown group member told me to try this place after colandrea in Caldor sold hasn’t been the same today went to caputos for lunch just to mention all the guys where friendly the pizza is now my new go to guy thanks for the experience
I'm typically in there for their grilled mixed vegetables that I bring back to the office, I usually bring chicken or shrimp from home to go with it. Always delicious!
Caputo is great. The food taste authentic and the service is caring. I visited the restaurant from New Windsor because a friend recommended it. The experience was worth the travel for sure and the food was affordable. You can't go wrong with the pizza, salad or pasta...I give 5 stars and 5 thumbs up to the pizza sauce?.
Some of, if not the best in Middletown. Always fresh and delicious. The staff is friendly and great. Even when they make a mistake they are quick to fix it. Can't recommend enough!!
Good pie needs more sauce in the middle of the pie. Liked the crust. Bottom was on the crispy side. I’d go back.
Unbelievably rude staff and sub par food. There are rude children running this place. The staff here runs wild the second the owner isn't there apparently. They were so rude to me I walked out the other day. Right before they "helped" me they were joking around on the phone with people trying to make orders. "Sorry, we don't have salad" and things of that nature. There are way better pizza places downtown that know how to treat their customers.
Terrible Food. Smelled disgusting when it got to my house. Waste of my money. Can't believe they threw big burnt slices of pizza in a box and delivered that. Chicken & mozzarella sticks were awful. Never ordering from here again.
Always a great meal, big portions for a great price ! Delivery time is spot on every time or even earlier, delivery guy is always polite “thank you for your business we really appreciate it “ !! When dining in , always friendly , fast service ! Give them a try never a disappointment ?
Ordered a chicken ranch pizza best pizza i ever had in a longtime. Also there delivery man Ross was very patient while I was fixing my payment method. Great customer service and great pizza
Ordered several items grilled chicken sandwich, chicken ala vodka were two of the items. the chicken was dry and tough in all of the items.(overcooked) in fairness the pasta was ok but the dry chicken ruined the dishes. I ate enough of the sandwich to soothe my appetite but threw Out more than half. The pizza was ok but not impressing And we were charged for garlic knots but never received them. I was recommended to this place so I was looking forward to trying it ,but I can’t say that I would go back.