Luigi's Pizza

39 Montauk Hwy, Lindenhurst - 11757
136 reviews
Pizza
(631) 991-7900

Their pizza is really good. The Sicilian is a long narrow piece but it's real good.

Catered from here yesterday, asked for 2pm delivery, they were here at 2pm. All my guests kept asking me where i ordered this food from, said was one of the best Eggplant parms they've ever had. Very reasonably priced. Plenty of food and more than enough bread and butter and parmesan cheese provided.

Love there Sicilian pie, or any pie we order, staff is great, the wonderful woman working behind the counter has a personality of a hard working and pretty much runs around doing many things, so I forgive her for coming off as a unhappy employee, after she slowed down a bit, we got to talking about there awesome selection of all kinds of Gelato, actually asked if there were any other kinds I like that weren't there, next time I ordered a pie, that Gelato was there, I was somewhat surprised !!!!The cooks are great and in and out service, as they were very busy - love that in a pizza parla!!I order my pies from there for now on, and can not leave without at least 2 gelatos!!

whenever I am back in town I always make it a point to stop and grab some pizza.

Clean place really good pizza ?

Real NYC style pizza. Tastes absolutely delicious no matter what pie you order. Heros are great and so are the pasta dishes.

Great food and amazing people. Every neighborhood needs a pizzeria like Luigi’s. Always friendly service that makes you feel like part of the family. Brought my son’s soccer team here to celebrate their season and they welcomed 14 loud 8 years with smiles on their faces. Can’t say enough good things, bottom line BEST PIZZERIA around!

Ordered last night for pick up after a family member had a bunch of pizzas for a party. Loved it at the party, was a bit disappointed last night. Perhaps their square pies are better. The round half pepp. I got last night had a few rookie mistakes (as someone who has worked at a pizza place) where the cheese-half had pepperoni on it, and the pizza didn't fit in the box leading to some wrinkled crusts. I saw some reviews saying their pizzas got smaller, a 16 inch at 14+ dollars isn't something to write home about in this area. I also personally believe the crust should be darker in color, slight browning on the bottom. Not pale. However still great pizza and I could tell everyone was working hard there. Not going to be my new favorite, but maybe every now and again.

Very nice pizzeria clean bright good variety the staff is polite and welcoming the pizza is good and fresh best in this area also a great value

Greta pizza with totally reasonable prices. Love this place.