Primo Piatto Ristorante & Pizzeria

138 E Main St, Huntington - 11743
203 reviews
Italian Pizza
(631) 935-1391

Food here at this nice neighborhood establishment is always very good! Service and meals were equally great.

We sat outside on the patio. Even though the restaurant is in a small shopping center the patio was secluded using flowers. The service was very good and accommodating. The tables had cloth tablecloths which made the dining experience pleasant. The food was good with large portions. Overall I would go back and recommend.

Food was excellent. Large portions. Sam, our waiter, was very personable and efficient.

Waitstaff was super friendly. Big comfortable table. Lobster dinner delicious and great deal for the price. Pizza was delicious.

Crispy Calamari a bit greasy though.Great SalmonGreat sausage and peppers hero Parmigiano.Also took out Shrimp Parmigiano hero.Got good remarks.Service friendly and polite though I think staff should dress more like waiters and waitresses.

The Wednesday lobster special ($19.99) was delicious. The lobster was cooked perfectly and was accompanied by a baked potato. It was NOT listed on the menu or specials.

Two nights in a row we ordered out. The first night I said okay, they had an off-night. I noticed a serious decline in the quality of food. I called and I was informed that they have a different owner. As I was giving the manager feedback, he didn’t like what I was sharing and he ended the call. The kitchen is run by a bunch of young people that have no clue what they’re doing and they are turning out mediocre Italian food. We have ordered from the restaurant from time to time over seven years and I was never treated so poorly. What a shame!

We live in the neighborhood and have enjoyed this restaurant many times. The pizza is great as are most of the dishes. Everyone at our table loved their meal. Except for me. Mine was just okay. It was the snapper special which was expensive and ordinary. Stick with chicken, pasta, pizza dishes. Plus the excellent salads. There was a huge table of about 20 women who were next to us that were horribly loud. The owner and waiter handled it beautifully and moved our table to the other end of the room when they saw how unhappy my group was. That resolved the problem satisfactorily. The wait staff couldn't have been more attentive or nicer. We are wine snobs so we brought our own bottles. We were charged a very reasonable corkage fee. All in all a good experience. I recommend this restaurant if you are looking for a low key neighborhood Italian place with nice food and friendly service.

Good wine and great food, great place for a date!!

Food was excellent !