Guiseppe's Pizza

1727 New York Ave, Huntington Station - 11746
197 reviews
Pizza Italian
(631) 351-6080

I used to love this place but lately the pizza has been very poor. It would do your business better to not sell next day pizza to customers who come in for lunch. I mean I get it, but I just got a very stale, old pizza slice and I paid 9.00 for a garlic knot slice and a regular slice. People should not have to eat garbage left overs to save you money.

Love the pizza here, especially this pizza with the sweet sauce! I love how you can get zeppoles and cannolis, along with lots of different options as far as specialty slices. They also make their own ice cream that you can buy, and the food is always really good. The pizza crust has sesame seeds which is my personal favorite! My only complaint would be that the food is a bit pricey, but basically in the range of other pizza places in the area.

Would go again, lots of options in their specialty slices. Some of their crust has garlic knots on them. They have a philly cheesesteak slice, won an award years ago.

I had really high expectations from this place...guess what...no way...1. Took an employee 10minutes to acknowledge I was trying to order. 2. The pizza guy was more concentrated on the cropped top red head coworker than my order. 3. Pizza was salty and dough weird...4. Not even Italian...don't know if anyone cares...but I would skip over this place

One of the best pizzas I have had. It kind of tasted like Naan but very delicious wish they have location near by as I am 50 mins away

I had really high expectations from this place...guess what...no way...1. Took an employee 10minutes to acknowledge I was trying to order. 2. The pizza guy was more concentrated on the cropped top red head coworker than my order. 3. Pizza was salty and dough weird...4. Not even Italian...don't know if anyone cares...but I would skip over this place

I can't begin to say how much of a great experience we had getting our food catered from Giuseppes Pizza. From the time we ordered our food to the time of delivery, everything was on point. We ordered food for 60 people and everyone had great things to say about the food. It was all amazing. Joe was so accommodating when we had some last minute additions and made sure we had everything we needed. Really a great guy. I would highly recommend Giuseppes when you're in the mood for a slice of pizza or if you need to cater food for a big event. Joe won't disappoint.

worst pizza ever, very rude, and the employee was not wearing gloves and somehow I found three long hair in my slice of pizza

I always use Guiseppe s for my catering.Joe and staff are great and they take care of everything and the food can’t be beat.I will use again for Christmas and New Year’s Eve.They are the best

One the best pizza on Long Island. They're speciality is the sweet sauce they use for their pie.I highly recommend the sweet pie.Plus they also have this garlic knot crust pie which is great too!!You can't go wrong and won't be disappointed.One negative is that during the summer its really hot inside the restaurant, but they have a nice outside seating area.