Pasta-eria

440 S Oyster Bay Rd, Hicksville - 11801
179 reviews
Italian Pizza
(516) 938-1555

We had my Moms 93rd birthday there tonight. The food was outstanding, the service was impeccable. We had a party of 15 and every single dish was fabulous and delicious. The owner and his family rock as well as the greatest staff. The desserts were outstanding. If you have not been there you need to try them. Big Mike, Mike and Melissa thanks for a great evening my mother had a blast. Thanks again for everything.

Good place to get pizza from. The staff is friendly and very nice. The garlic knots are great and go fantastic with the tomato sauce.

I have been eating at Pasta-Eria for many years. The food is delicious and the food is fresh and hot. It is a very friendly atmosphere. All the waiters are terrific. One in particular is Noel . . . He is very respectful, checks on us during our meal and extremely pleasant. I highly recommend Pasta-Eria. Lily

We had been going here several times a month for many years and in the past the food and service in the restaurant has usually been excellent, including terrific servers like Reuben, Paul and Marco. Unfortunately, the takeout service in the front of the Pasta-eria restaurant had deteriorated to the lowest level. We have tried to continue to patronize this place during COVID-19 by using takeout and as of late service has been downright rude and nasty. Even the salad dressing that we like to takeout has been watered down, inedible, and adulterated and most recently we returned with the almost full container and these unpleasant people denied it was theirs even though we had a paid receipt from them and they would not replace it. I am sad to say that they have lost formerly happy and reliable customers, never to return!

Great food ! Exceptional service . Noel , Marco and Ruben are incredibly attentive . Love this place been coming for years ! A must try every meal is fresh , hot and the potions are hard to beat . Cater for your next party . They won’t disappoint

Food is prepared perfectly! Great atmosphere will definitely be back on my out of town work trips!

BBQ Sicilian: Perfection!

BBQ Sicilian: Perfection!

Italian food at it’s best. Every time I’m nearby with my daughter (it’s hers most favorite place) we get takeout. Highly recommend.

Just ordered from Pasteria. We order every Friday night and also use them for parties. Our order has been wrong many times before and I just let it slide. Ordered specifically fried chicken, zoodles and sauce on the side. Got spaghetti with sauce. Called and nicely explained the mistake. The girl who is the owners daughter/sister got and she was argumentative immediately. Put me on the phone with Michael the “owner/ chef” as he said. He said I don’t know what a zoodle is, said I guess she thought you said “noodles”. I explained I went over it 3x. He said oh we called them zuchini noodles. I said well the person I ordered it for can’t eat pasta so can you just charge me for the chicken cutlet since half the meal is garbage. He said we can only credit you if we bring it back. I explained we are not able to and he said then i don’t know what to tell you. Not only did he refuse but he got extremely rude and condescending. I told him I was a loyal customer and that he just lost a customer. He said I could care less and hung up. Not only did he lose a customer but he is not aware that I work locally and my place of business places big orders and also frequents there for lunch. No more! I guess marrying what he thinks is “fame” got to his head. Never been spoken with such disrespect from an establishment. He’d rather lose a customer than eat the difference. Never again. I’ve seen other people recently complain on here, stay away. There is much better locally. When I posted my review on social media the owner actually came on and accused me of lying! This was after me stating I have been a loyal customer for years. Seems their ego means more to them than a customer for years!