This place has served the best pizza (square) for more than sixty years
We got a supreme pizza from Pizza Supreme and it wasn't your average supreme. It was WAYY above average, with slices soo big and toppings piled high. Their wings are also top notch! Ordered for delivery, they were super fast!
Squar slice ? reg slice ?There doe sauce and cheese combination is great ?️ slice on the floppy side but flavor is delicious.I have not eaten more the 2 slices from other places. For me to deviouer half a pie yeah thats good. ? ? ? ?
This pizza is below averageI wouldn't waste my money or my timeAnd the workers act like you have to speak spanish to them to get service
Great pizza. Great staff. Just don’t like that they don’t wear masks.
perfect pizza every time!
Pizza and service is all top shelf. Counter people are very professional and the Pizza is absolutely delicious.
Pizza Supreme was my favorite pizza, ate lunch there every day in the 60’s when they were in Massapequa before the Mall and Garden City. A few years ago I was back on Long Island and stopped in for a corner square slice and it was exactly as I remembered it from 55 years ago. Still delicious
The Best!!! Been going there for over 30+ years, even back when they were in the mall. The square pie is unique and well worth the drive.
I've been eating here since they were in Roosevelt Field Mall right next to Connie's Shoes back in the early 80's. The best Pizza in New York hands down is the square Pie.