John Anthony's

365 Atlantic Ave, Freeport - 11520
100 reviews
Pizza
(516) 223-6770

I absolutely love that place they taste so good I remember in elementary school I always eat John Anthony pizza almost every day and sometimes I go with my grandma or grandpa so we can order and get the pizza i went there from 2nd grade - 4th grade I moved to another state when I was 10 im 12 now I’m back for the summer and I live super close to the place

Consistently good quality and tasty food. I’ve tried many of their menu items and everything has been great. I usually order delivery through the Slice website, food orders have always arrived accurate and very hot.

Great staff. Delicious food.

Ordered twice on grubhub. Both times they waited forty five minutes before cancelling the order because they were too busy

I live near here for years and never ordered I always go out my way for good pizza! Well no longer will! I have super picky kids and 1 friend that doesn’t eat pizza well to my surprise she ate the pizza! That says it all my new pizza location! I’d recommend

Absolutely terrible! All dishes are not cooked well. Gallant effort,but not quite there! Owner is very self absorbed! Owner has made up her mind because she's the proprietor, customers, and their opinions just don't matter. Very shallow person! Another example, if you have a couple of dollars,anyone can own a pizzeria! Only thing is,can anyone cook? That's the key! So many Pizzerias, you don't have to settle for tasteless food! It's your money! Don't throw it away and be dissatisfied! Move on and away from this tasteless joint!

The best in town. I was given a wrong pie but after talking to the manager he said come pick up the right pie without a charge. Much appreciated. Please continue your hospitality.

No consistency- it was great a few months a go, maybe the inflation force to change ingredients or different pizza maker ? ? did not enjoy it as I thought I will, cheese was tasteless and hardly taste the sauce...my rate is 5/5 is just football pizza, actually frozen pizza taste better.

A piece was really good the service from the workers was really nice family-friendly Place advise anybody to take their family they eat really good pizza

I came back here after a visit a few months ago because I was impressed with the food and service. Not to mention two pretty girls behind the counter helps. I'll be back and the price for 2 pies and a drink under $40 is a deal that's worth the the drive from Queens