Harleys American Grille

283 Main St, Farmingdale - 11735
557 reviews
Steak House American Seafood
(516) 586-8000

Beautiful clean atmosphere, accommodating staff, very friendly, pleasant and Excellent service and food.

Very disappointed, waited over an hour for our food. Overpriced surf & turf $86 was way overcooked. Large party of 14 next to us must have overwhelmed the kitchen. Did not complain to waitress since it was not her fault. Will not be returning.

TOO MANY FLIES. Nasty. Windows were closed and yet there were fruit flies all around our table and food.

Went for the first time on Father's Day. Place was pretty empty on a Sunday at 5:30 and never really got busy. They were very accommodating with table selection which was appreciated. Drinks rolled out smoothly as well as appetizers. We had an oyster special which was good. Our waiter took our order shortly after and was pretty attentive in the beginning of service. 5 minutes after ordering dinner a server dropped us 1 side of mac & cheese very randomly. We were a group of 7 by the way. We laughed as the side sat and sat and sat... asked the server as he passed again and he said "your food is coming right out". 10 minutes after the side was dropped we finally saw our waiter again who agreed that the side should not have been brought out and our food was not nearly ready. Very odd. When the meals did come out they were together - steaks & tuna were good. There was a big menu discrepancy on a pasta dish - the pasta was CLEARLY stuffed with something and the menu description never stated this - whatever it was tasted very potent, like a blue cheese which is not for everyone - the kitchen disputed this but we like food & were pretty confident in our assessment - we spoke to a manager & our waiter and they took it off the bill which we appreciated. We ordered coffees & dessert - this is where things got really annoying - some drinks NEVER made their way out. The coffees/cappuccinos came out - we drank them and finished them - still no sight of dessert. Finally 1 dessert comes out... we continue waiting... 10 more minutes passes & the waiter comes over to tell us the other desserts we ordered were no longer available. WHAT?!?! As a customer, my biggest pet peeve is not being able to drink my coffee with my dessert - what's the point otherwise?! As far as the other desserts not being "available" sounds like nonsense to me - I think the waiter forgot or there was a mix up in the kitchen - just a poor ending to a just okay dinner. I would not come here again for the lack of detail the staff seems to have. Also the food is just okay and for the price they're charging, there are several other places I'd rather spend my money.

The place was decent looking. Staff was very friendly. My husband had their burger which he said was great. Myself and the other 2 in our party had the steak sandwich. 2 were supposed to be med rare and one med. They were all on the rare side and uneatable. Rubber best describes it. We told them. They were apologetic and didn’t charge us for the 3 steak sandwiches. Don’t think we’ll be going back though.

Let me just start by saying… the french fries… I really didn’t think it was possible to mess these up. But they had to be the absolute worst fries any of us ever had. And when the waiter asked how was everything, we told him about the fries and his response was “that’s not the first time I’ve heard that.” I’m very curious if the chef has ever tried these french fries and how after repeated complaints can they still serve them. The bread that was served at the table was just as bad as the fries. Nothing was really that great, and the service was terrible. Needless to say, we will not be visiting again.

disappointing. some of the food was barely edible. the steak was good.

Garden omelette was so tasty! Bellinis were great!!

The room was so cold and we addressed with the waiter who claims he had adjusted it but it never warmed up when we were there. We ordered, mostly appetizers and a burger. I sent back my lamp chops and asked to speak to a manager and no one bothered to come by. And it wasn’t even busy! To serve 4 lamb chops and 2 to be raw was ridiculous! Our waiter was nice when he stopped by! He could Have been much more attentive. Even the hostess refilled our water since he was not coming around enough! Not a fan!

Great place - great food and excellent service every time!