Felico's Catering

85 Allen Blvd, Farmingdale - 11735
112 reviews
Caterers Pizza Specialty Food
(631) 777-1999

Their retail department is closed. I didnt get anything. They should split catering and retail into 2 so that people who want pizza will know not to come here

Very annoying! They call themselves a pizzeria but their pizzeria has been closed since Oct 2021. Time to change your name - Felicos Caterig Service.

I can’t say enough how pleased I am with Felico’s! I recently threw a 60th birthday party for my parent’s at the VFW Hall in Albertson. I worked closely with Frank, the owner of Felico’s, to book the hall. He was extremely kind and always willing to help answer any questions I had during the planning process. This was the ideal venue for my parent’s party and was spacious, newly renovated, and nicely decorated.In addition to the hall rental, they offered very generous and affordable catering packages including an open bar, appetizers, several main courses, and dessert, all catered by Felico’s. I also communicated with Joann, who was very sweet and helpful while making arrangements for the hall and food. We received several compliments from party guests on how delicious the food was. I was very happy with the quality and wide selection they offered! We also had two guests who had dairy allergies which they kindly accommodated with individual dishes. The staff who assisted during the party was also extremely professional and always willing to help with whatever we needed.Frank also helped suggest a DJ for us as well! As a first time party planner, it was such a pleasure to work with Frank, Joann, and the Felico’s staff to make the planning for my parent’s 60th birthday party as seamless as possible. We received several compliments on the hall, food, and entertainment, and I credit it all to the help Felico’s staff. I highly recommend them for any party you’re looking to host – thank you Felico’s!

Felico’s is the real deal. My husband and I had the absolute BEST backyard wedding and we couldn’t have done it without the team at Felico’s. Not only was the food incredible (and trust me…we had a lot of tough critics) everything was taken care of. The ambience was truly amazing because we had an unbelievable team backing us up.Jenn is simply the best. I can’t say it enough. Within a week I felt like I knew her forever and had no doubt we were in safe hands. She was the leader we needed and the one the whole staff responded to and respected leading up to the event and day of. She delivered on every promise she made and more.Frank is fantastic! He made sure everything was perfect and went out of his way to show up every time we needed him. He was very willing to work with us every step of the way to make sure that he could deliver us a truly amazing experience that fit within our budget. He was a true hands-on owner.I can’t recommend this business enough. The food, the ambience, the love!If anyone has any questions at all, feel free to DM me.

Would not recommend this place at all ... if you want good catered food go to someone who doesn't try to squeeze you for every item

They catered a party for about 30 people for me in December. For a passed hors d'oeuvre style I repeatedly mentioned that I didn't think one server would be enough for 30 people and they consistently reassured me. I figured they do this all the time and so I trusted their judgement. Seven people cancelled at the last minute and we had 23 guests. The single server still wasn't adequate and most people at the back of the party rarely saw any food at all. The food was fine. The staff was friendly but I was fairly disappointed.

Food is good but absolutely way to expensive. It should not be 15 dollars for a small plate of lunch

Have To Say, Had A Graduation Party This Weekend, We Had It Catered By Fellicos As A Recommendation.A Definite 10 Stars - The Food Was Fantastic, Really Really Good ??

We had a graduation party this weekend and everyone raved about the food!!! It was delicious and fresh! Eggplant, rigatoni Genovese, steak scallopine, penne vodka, roasted potatoes and chicken with asparagus, salad and rolls….all delicious. They also delivered it timely! Eha was a pleasure to work with and answered all my questions! We went with one of the packages they offered. Highly recommend and will use them again for future catering needs!

I just had my party catered yesterday and as usual, the food was absolutely delicious! I've been using Felicos for 17 years for all of my catered parties. Sometimes I switch the menu up, which I did yesterday and all of the new dishes are just as good if not better than the others I always get! It's never a disappointment, so delicious and they give you plenty of food! ?????