Hill Top

171 Jerusalem Hill Rd, Elmira - 14901
121 reviews
American
(607) 732-6728

We have enjoyed eating dinner at Hilltop many times in the past but last night was very disappointing. First I would like to mention that the atmosphere and view are wonderful but unfortunately our meal and the service left much to be desired. We ordered some starters and drinks which we enjoyed, but our shrimp scampi was delivered to our table very dry, with no sauce of any kind. It consisted of dry angel hair pasta with some shrimp on top. We let our waiter know and he took our plates back. When he returned our dinners they had some kind of watery mix added. We decided to eat it anyway but we did let the server know that it wasn’t really acceptable. He said he was sorry. We chose to skip dessert as we weren’t sure what that would be like. We went to a different restaurant and enjoyed a nice dessert elsewhere. We were disappointed that no one offered to make the situation right. We will not be having dinner at this restaurant again, which is a shame because we do enjoy the view!

I’ve lived in the area for all my life. We frequently visit this restaurant because I love the environment, food, staff and views. The staff is so amazing and the food is always delicious. However… we went up today for the first time for a holiday dinner which we usually stay home for…. I decided I did not want to do all the work this year and said we are going to the Hill! Wow!! I was so impressed, food was amazing, service was still fabulous and I did not have to do dishes!!! Thank you Mike, Jeremie, and staff!!!

Went to hilltop inn for a memorial luncheon for a coworker that passed away, the food was all leftover garbage from the day before which was st. patricks day. The food that was served was left over corned beef and grilled cheese sandwiches, left over shepards pie and soup and cookies. The owner charged 23 dollars a plate for food that i wouldnt feed to my dog. I have seen better food served at the soup kitchen that i volunteer for. The event was from 3 to 6 pm, the food was taken away at 5:15 and the owner rudely came out and announced it was 5pm and everybody had to go outside or to the corner of the restaurant. Also, i failed to mention he charged 375 dollars for the cookies that you can buy at sams club for 50 dollars. The current owner of the restaurant is just an arrogant ,money hungry person, nothing like his father when he operated the business when you got a great meal. It was sad and disgusting that mike sullivan took advantage of people at such a time of loss. Shame on you mike sullivan for the leftovers you served to paying customers!

The corn beef was sliced thin and delicious and for dessert mint ice cream pie. Yum Listening to Pat Kane

Great view. Great food. Fabulous service!

Excellent, friendly, knowledgeable trader . Fast, convenient, affordable service. I highly recommend Kathrine Lucas she made over $12,000 with just the minimum investment of $1000 on my trading account . Contact her one WhatsApp+12523688769 or Email:[email protected]

What a feast! They served turkey, beef, and ham with every side dish you could imagine (except for their outstanding Brussel sprouts). The turkey was moist and the mac and cheese was mmmm good! The service was outstanding, and even with a large crowd, the staffing was very adequate. Our server, Seth, saw to every need. The owner stopped by all the tables to personally greet you. Our entire family was so satisfied with the choice of Hilltop Inn for our Thanksgiving dinner. Thanks for an enjoyable day.

Hill Top is an excellent place to have a quiet dinner for two or a gathering of many. Mike Sullivan is an excellent host and his wait staff is premium. Thank you so much for hosting us this evening and giving us such a great service with the most delicious food!

Great food. Great atmosphere. Love this place!!

We loved our Friday night dinner on the deck. No bugs, great weather, view, service and food.