Caffè Italia

1745 Deer Pk Ave, Deer Park - 11729
133 reviews
Ice Cream Shop Coffee & Tea Gelato
(631) 667-0201

They have the best gelato and coffee on the Island.My favorite gelato flavors are the Tiramisu (has lady fingers in it), the Amarena and the Wildberries Mascarpone.The espresso is smooth and strong.The customer service is top notch. Lots of regular customers.

What a great find this place was. As far as I can tell they only serve coffee, espresso, gelato and some pastries, but no complaint from me.I had an Espresso Affogato, which is a a shot of espresso over gelato. What a great treat.

Amazing Gelatos. A taste of Italy in Deer Park! Amazing service, amazing atmosphere, and very helpful staff. I swear the time I was eating the gelato I felt no worries, no stress, no tensions, just heavenly bliss! Thank you for giving me such a wonderful experience! Stay blessed.

Saw the great reviews and decided to stop in for a coffee and pastry. The place looks modest on the outside. Don't let the modesty fool you. They make a perfect cappuccino. Just perfect. And the Sfogliatelle was the best I've ever eaten. The best and all the others completely forgotten. The people are warm and the service is attentive and personal. Lovely place. Can't wait to come back.

The only option for gelato if you can't go to Italy to get it. The gelato is perfection. The espresso and cappuccino are exceptional. And the random imported treats that bring me back to my childhood summers are the final piece to a perfect outing.

There is NO BETTER Gelato anywhere on Long Island.. Great staff, OH how could I not mention the espresso, Incredible**..

Amazing little hidden Italian gem! Had great selection of self-made smooth, decadent and refreshing gelatos and sorbets. Great selection of hot and cold coffee drinks as well. I so wish this place was closer to us. I also wish the owner would contact me so I can co-invest with him on a few other locations... there is a huge need for gelatos on certain areas of LI! Do not wait and pass this place by.

Cute little café. Yummy gelato and hot cocoa.

Best gelato and ice coffee in long Island .

Great Gelato, many flavors.