Prime Burger Bar

6092 Jericho Turnpike, Commack - 11725
180 reviews
Burgers Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt American
(631) 486-9414

Went once with my husband and the service was great. Our waitress was very kind and the ambiance was very laid back. The food however wasn’t too good, the buffalo wings didn’t have much sauce on it and the loaded fries had way too much chives on it. The drinks were great and would recommend the espresso martini. Not sure if I’d go back again but I’d say to try this place at least once.

Great setting, great burgers, awesome jumbo pretzel! We will be back for sure!!! I had the bbq burger and my girlfriend had the tuna burger - more like a tuna steak and she loved it. Sweet potato waffle fries and regular fries were great!

Very good food & very pleasant service staff. Great Music listening to Danny Kean!

Everything about the place was great ( Manager and staff were Awesome) , and especially the music outside under the tent with The Shoobies !!!!!!!

One of the best burgers I've ever had. Great service decent value. 2 apps, 2 drinks each, 1 burger each, $75.00

Amazing food and service!

The burgers were delicious.. the fries were great. The shakes were good alsothe food was hot which is always a plusbut the service was horrible ....it took over an hour to get our food.. the waitress was not very attentive.. the worst part was that we got a everything pretzel ( an appetizer) and not the Bavarian one that we ordered after we got served our meal and it was very hard.I would go there againbut id either eat first or not go when im hungry...

When your burgers come out, your jaw will drop when you see how tall they are. Hint we got - either really squeeze or cut them down to size! I actually had the ribeye sandwich, with mozzarella, caramelized sweet onions - sauces on the side (my preference). The meat can be a bit tough, but it has been nicely marinated, cooked perfectly, and is worth the effort. It comes with fries, but I substituted (small premium) onion rings, which were good. The 2 others with me had burgers - both really liked them. Know that the burgers are made with various mixtures of meat, I believe half a pound before cooking. I was told that the sweet potato waffle fries were good. The 'seasonal soups were as recall, loaded potato and Italian Wedding Soup. I had the latter, but it was a bit short on flavor (a bit of salt should help). I had a chocolate milkshake - not huge, but well blended, very chocolatey, one of the better I've had. The pretzels are huge, crispy, hot, and tasty. Staff were friendly, always helpful. One oddity - the soup arrived a minute behind the entrees. Not sure if that was supposed to happen that way or not, but if you are getting a soup, let them know when you will want it. The place looks small - until you notice another room in the back. It's a bit pricey - but ingredients are of good quality. We're not talking McD's here. Well worth coming back! One reminder - I believe that Mondays and Tuesdays they open at 4PM, other days earlier.

Interesting place. Think of Applebee's or a Long Island Diner, but much better.Seemingly, this is an old classic neighborhood bar turned into a bar with a casual restaurant now. The end to end bar still dominates the main dinning area.The menu is mostly versions of half pound burgers. There are several classic comfort food appetizers too.And you can top off your experience by indulging on a massive "extra" milkshake in the $15 range.

Still trying to find a burger that rivals 5280 in Denver and while Prime Burger was tasty it didn't match up. The employees were all friendly, service was quick, the burger while not cooked as requested tasted good and the poutine was better than most places. I would return if in the area to try another buyer and maybe a dessert or a shake next trip.