Emilio's

2201 Jericho Turnpike, Commack - 11725
387 reviews
Pizza Italian Seafood
(631) 462-6267

Food and atmosphere are great. Service was awesome. Never disappoints.

Food is always good. We sat at the bar to have dinner where Stacy the bartender takes good care of us. We both had pasta dishes and an antipasto. Everything was great.

Always Delicious and consistent!!!! Friendly staff and the restaurant is spotless.

Delicious food, good portions and excellent service

Made a 7p reservation on open table- for 7 people. Didn’t get seated until 740p. Otherwise no issues

Excellent food and great service. Extensive menu and great specials. Always a nice experience to eat and socialize.

Always great. Took a friend for their first time. Loved it.

Expensive for very mediocre food. Definitely not going back.

not sure what is happening with emilios. was my fav spot but the service was horrible. specifically the man that sat us. how rude told us he would sit us in a booth then gave it away and the when I said I didn’t want to sit it the noisy area rolled his eyes and told me it’s sat night I should want to be in a loud area. 30 minutes to just get bread not even sure it mattered that I had an open table reservation he just out me on the list like everyone else. going to have to find a new fav spot after 30 years. sad

Been coming here for over 20 years, but will no longer. The food quality has gone downhill over the last several years, service is consistently bad with wrong orders OFTEN and rude staff, and prices have been jacked up even before the pandemic.Mother's Day dinner was prefixed menu for $50 per person (not including upgraded options such as burrata and not including dessert), which was not communicated when the reservation was made. Complete ripoff plus appetizers all coming at different times.The prefixed menu was limited with options such as spaghetti with butter sauce for $50!!!!I will not be returning- I almost never write reviews and the ones I do are usually extremely positive, but this place has gone off a cliff