Really good pizza and an incredible rewards program!We had the roasted cauliflower (pictured) and the traditional (basically their regular cheese). Both were delicious. The cheese pie was really good; our kids loved it. Totally worth it. The cauliflower was tasty, but would probably order something different next time.We signed up for their rewards program after our server recommended it and are really happy about the bonuses they offer! A free 12” for signing up, a birthday pizza… good stuff for sure.We sat at the outdoor seating in front of the restaurant. Really not bad at all considering that the restaurant fronts onto JTPKE.
I ordered the eggplant pizza, coal fried wings and a Caesar salad from the Commack location… the pizza was awful.. it was described to have eggplant, sauce and Romano cheese-it was so dry and tasteless and there was maybe 5 grains of cheese.. they gave me the wrong salad and the wings should have been named coal burnt wings.. I saw the reviews but decided to give it a try anyway and I’m so mad that I did.. never again, such a shame ??
First time going to Commack site. Nick our bartender was awesome. However the placed was packed and the only bartender was him. Ordered wings that never came out on time so I had to take them to go. Need to have at least 2 bartenders on a Friday night.
They have such great wings. Tried the cauliflower pizza they have too and that was really yummy.
Cosmo was strong and salad was wet but fresh. Pizza amayas usual.
Love the place but part of tonight's pickup order looked like this. This should've never left the restaurant like this thinking it's ok.Coal fired doesn't mean burnt.Let me know how your talk with management goes. Never ordering again.
The food has always been overpriced for the quality when compared to other local pizzerias but now the service has also steadily decreased. Ordered delivery and got the same order wrong twice within the same hour. If you like your wings covered in charcoal so thick that there's barely any chicken left, then this is the place for you.
It’s pizza at its best! The salad is great!
Limited menu but wonderful pizza and salads!
I ordered takeout the other night from here on Friday. I got the carnivori pizza.. talk about food poisoning. My girlfriend and I were sick all night, out the top and the bottom. What a terrible experience. May never eat here again..