The food was delicious from appetizers, main dishes, dessert and even the wine was delicious. A cute atmosphere inside. I was able to have a relaxing and peaceful beautiful night there for it being my first time eating there. They have a great selection of food and drinks. The staff is so polite and nice. Even though they are located in the busy Hertel Avenue it was definitely worth eating in and I would recommend.
Romeo and Juliet's on Hertel Ave in Buffalo was the worst experience I have had in any city in recent history! Not one the appetizers or entrees came out hot! After we sent 2 things back to the kitchen, the cook came out and yelled at us! I would not go back there if the food was free!!
Always fantastic and consistent from service to food. The pizzas are amazing and creative, the salads can feed a whole family and the pasta fagiole is to die for. The bakery is great too, I've stopped by many times on walk to pickup tomato pies or bruschetta on the front table for a quick dinner. Much respect and love for Romeo and Juliet's... they were the "Hertel Strip" before it was ever a destination.
The food was amazing, it was very flavorful and delicious!!! Every bite keeps you wanting more!!! If your looking for some Italian food that will knock you off you feet, come here and eat!!!!
I’m soo going to miss the food they serve when I go back home! Lobster ravioli was delicious!!!
I had the lobster Ravioli and it was incredible, also had their lasagna which was very delicious, however the lobster ravioli is just to die for. I'll definitely be returning often.
So many people rave about thier pizza so I thought I was in for a treat. At best it is mediocre. The dough is good but the sauce and cheese seems to be very low quality. The price was a little high as well for the size of the pizza.Bakery was good but it sells out of stuff fast and apparently the two locations have differant options.Staff is polite but not all that helpful.
I have ordered take out and delivery through Uber Eats MANNnny times, also 1 dine in experience. Every single time it's consistently DELICIOUS. Fresh bread and tasty Italian dishes including paninis.
What a wonderful little place! Just passing through and wanted to find a small cafe. Food was AMAZING and service dog friendly! The owner made the entire experience. He was super friendly and accommodating to our Guide Dog pups in training. I wish I lived closer. If you are going through Buffalo, this cafe is a MUST!
The menu is delicious across the board. Knocks the socks off Italian restaurants in the area that are charging three times as much. If you go out to eat because you like food, this is a restaurant for you.