Johnny's Meat Market

1191 Hertel Ave, Buffalo - 14216
72 reviews
Butcher Meat Shops
(716) 876-2500

Best steaks! buy them here, make at home and save a ton!!! Staff is courteous and knowledgeable. It was a pleasure, thank you!

Nice family atmosphere, been there since I been in Buffalo from Atlanta. Love this place.

My go to place for the best meats around. A classic italian butcher shop.Helpful,knowledgeable staff.

Wonderful service. I'm on oxygen and someone helped me with my bag to my car. The slab bacon is to die for. Its not fatty just great. And my eggs i bought from them. My only regret is that i didn't buy enough of the bacon. So i will have to go back and get triple my order of it. My new store to go to.

As a family we are life long customers and I just left there trying to buy 10 2 inch T-bone steaks for Father’s Day and was told no because they only use the saw once a week or because he didn’t feel like cutting them… bad service for customers!

Horrible communication, I drove 30 mins to this butcher after I called for a case of wings. I show up and they say they don't have a case.

I’d like to give a 5⭐️PLUS rating. Never have I had anything other than exemplary service in 35 years. The friendliest crew is behind the counter. “Izzy’s sauce” is a staple in our household. Our freezer has a reserved spot for it ! Their Italian and chicken sausages are the absolute best. Want a real treat ? Try the freshly sliced roast beef that comes with au jus. Looking forward to spaghetti tonight. Better go pick up some meatballs ! Yummmmm.

I stumbled upon Johnny’s day before Christmas Eve. Purchase a prime rib. Price was fantastic, service was excellent. The prime rib was the best tasting prime rib I’ve ever made. Johnny’s will now be a staple for meats for my household! So glad I discovered this gem!

I stumbled upon Johnny’s day before Christmas Eve. Purchase a prime rib. Price was fantastic, service was excellent. The prime rib was the best tasting prime rib I’ve ever made. Johnny’s will now be a staple for meats for my household! So glad I discovered this gem!

Great old fashioned butcher shoppe with so much more to add to your grocery list. Chuck roast was superb!