Impeccable. You get what you pay for. (Their whitefish salad seems to have more real fish than appetizer places, so less mayo, more bright with lemon and slight dill.) Oysters from Maine were at good price. Good selection of preparation condiments and some lentils and pasta and boxed flatbread. Gems of canned fish and shellfish. Kind and attentive counter person.
I will never get seafood from anywhere else. Just the freshest!
Their seafood is incredibly fresh and they are transparent with their sourcing. Get their weekly fish share by joining their CSF (csa for fish) and never buy fish anywhere else again.
The fish is always fresh and delicious. You can see where it was caught, and how. Transparent and local as can be. Love it
A friendly excellent fish store selling pristine, ethically caught fish and some tasty prepared items. Their fish share program is a good "catch". A bit pricy compared to more mass market suppliers but reasonable for the excellent quality and service.
This is possibly my favorite purveyor in NYC. Best fish I’ve ever had hands down - great emails too!
Absolutely incredible. Why not make two decadent dinners on a Monday and Tuesday? The fish was delicious in every way… can’t wait to come back again
I joined the weekly fish share recently and feel demonstrably happier and healthier, for a very reasonable price considering the quality. And I'm just learning more about more fish. Plus, the people at MG are nice, helpful, and knowledgeable. A+
My go-to for amazing quality fish
Went on New Year’s eve. The lone was long bc of Covid but it mi Ed quickly. They were knowledgeable and helpful w my choices. The oysters were fresh and exactly as they described them.