Went to the new location on Quentin Road. I got a roast beef with cheese and mayo on a roll and Turkey with Cheese and Mustard on a hero. Combined it cost $14 and $13 (Total 27). Could get it cheaper at other good Brooklyn Deli’s. If the price was a lower I would go back.
The chicken cutlet sandwich and Italian combo were SO GOOD. I saw someone else getting a roast beef sandwich that looked good too. The people who work here were really nice - they threw in 2 cannoli for free
This place has the nicest staff ever! The heros are delicious! We had the chicken cutlet with garlic mayo and fresh mozzarella and the hot Italian, we weren’t able to finish them they were so big. Both were delicious, wish we had time to try everything!
Delicious chicken cutlet sandwich! Very friendly and efficient staff!
I came here for a sandwich on national sandwich day. I hadn't been here since I was a kid so I didn't know what to expect. I ordered a homemade roast beef sandwich and it was delicious. The staff was super friendly and took pride in the food they made, which they should because it's great.
Best sandwich shop without a doubt. Never fails. Amazing staff and amazing food, you'll love the vibe in there as much as you'll love the sandwiches. They close early so sometimes I miss out but definitely a must try for everyone.
We walked in just as a batch of cutlets came fresh out of the oven. We were hungry and unsure what to order so we asked Vic to create something for us with the cutlets. He didn't miss a beat and started throwing together fresh veggies and condiments. I'm honestly not sure what all of the ingredients were but it was one of the best heros we've ever tasted. The guy knows his sandwiches and he truly blessed it for us, even threw in a few cannolis. We will definitely be stopping by more often. If you are looking for delicious sandwiches and subs and kind, friendly service in the Sheepshead Bay area, this is the spot!
Jimmy's Famous Sandwich shop makes some of the best sandwiches in the Sheepshead Bay area. The sandwich maker Vic, is such a great guy, also his wife and crew are all the best! I threw him for a loop & got a chicken cutlet & roast beef sandwich with garlic mayo lettuce tomato s&p oil &vinegar. It came delicious! Will be ordering this again for a cool summer sandwich. Disclaimer/not they were running low on bread the sandwich with rb & chicken cutlet is a half hero portion.The pics after Vic's photo are full hero pics(with plastic half pints of mac & potato salads). The salads were free gifts from this awesome shop. These guys are the best in the neighborhood, come here when you have a hankering for a well made sandwich!
The best sandwiches in town. The bread is always fresh and there’s so many options to choose from. The Italian combo and chicken cutlet one are my favs. Can’t go wrong with any of the sandwiches ??
We stopped here for sandwiches on the way to the beach and were pleased to find they offered a vegetarian option for those who dont eat meat. The sandwich included fresh mozz, lettuce, tomato, onions, pickles, and some really good roasted/marinated peppers. They also offered eggplant and garlic mayo as options as well! Thanks for the vegetarian options!I got a chicken cutlet and it was great! Thank you Jimmy!