Blue Marble Ice Cream

186 Underhill Ave, Brooklyn - 11238
154 reviews
Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Coffee & Tea
(718) 399-6926

The counter person handed my 10 year old her $9 single scoop ice cream cone and said, “Be careful, the cone is cracked.” After politely asking for some solution, three counter people stared blankly and one hands me a tiny cup, “just in case”. I was just speechless. I still am but had to tell this story.

The pistachio almandine is epic!

Ye who enter shall be rewarded. Go weird or go home. Make sure to sample tho some of the flavors lack, well, flavor. But order right and you’ll remember that on your deathbed.

A great ice cream stop before heading for a stroll in Prospect Park. I ordered a waffle cone with a split scoop consisting of a mix between nitro cold brew and organic maple. It was quite a tasty treat, including the taste of the waffle cone. I expect this store to get busier as the weather gets warmer. I would definitely return for another treat.

The blue marble ice cream is very good!

I really enjoy the ice cream, but their single for $6 is so tiny (think golf ball), it makes me really sad. I recommend buying a pint to go for better value.

Wonderful place with delicious ice cream. Outdoor seating. Not too expensive. Rotating seasonal flavours.

Highly recommend the cold brew. Nice staff and lots of outdoor seating

I use to visit Blue Marble. Even referred several neighbors. But, of late, one or two of the wait staff is out right rude.One woman in particular has such a negative attitude. She presents as though she is not happy to be at work. She is miserable and for no apparent reason.. Not good customer service and her performance is unacceptable . Particularly, for the neighborhood that supports the very wages she is a stewart of via the pay check she quickly accepts.I hope their will be improvements to the effect.Thank you just the same.

The ice cream is always delicious, I wish they hade cake cones