*Chef's kiss* Had the Paisano it was everything I expected and more. Came from London to try the Hero's as they were well recommended on various social media. Lovely lady at the counter (I think she was a daughter of the owner?) said I wouldn't be disappointed and by God she was right. It was a beautiful sandwich. My only regret was not having more stomachs to try all the flavours I wanted to in one sitting. I will be back - I have a list of flavours/a checklist if you will, that I need to go through. Mark my words I will back. Excellent atmosphere, excellent food, excellent polite and quick service. Keep doing what you are doing!
This place lives up to the hype. I ordered my hero’s as takeout and I was in and out. I tried the Roast Beast Hero and my partner got the God Father (sweet). Both delicious and freshly made. Will be back to try other options.
Great and consistent quality. How do I know?I've had four sandwiches in the past seven days because after the first I can't help but crave the godfather.I recently wanted a solid cold cut and peppers sandwich with no frills and I'll be honest I hate lettuce. It's a filler ingredient and at best doesn't harm a sandwich but adds nothing that another better ingredient can't. This was the place I found from searching that actually has good sounding sandwiches which use good greens in sandwiches that add flavor like arugula or spinach. The spicy peppers are great too
This is hands down the best sandwich shop in the area. I’ve been coming here for years and it never disappoints. Fresh ingredients & great bread! I don’t get why people complain about high prices. You get what you pay for! Plus the serving sizes are more then generous. Anthoney & Sons is the real deal.
First timer. I got the Graham Ave sandwich. The roast beef was too dry. The sandwich was built pretty good. Definitely will go back as the menu is very large.
Best of the best when it comes to sandwiches. Will leave you wanting to try everything on the menu. And acts like a bodega with tons of drinks and snacks to buy.
Wow!!! This was the laziest sandwich DON’T bother going here. This was the second time, it sucked last time so I ordered this time with EXTRA SAUCE, GRATED CHEESE AND SALT AND PEPPER. I had a traditional chicken parm hero and the FDNY. They were both dried out, minimal sauce and $30 for 2 sandwiches. The girlcharged me $4.00 per sandwich for the grated cheese, she said “it’s 2 cheeses”. Sandwiches were so tasteless I went back in to get more grated cheese to try to get some flavor from these and the ANGRY OWNER had the girl at register charge me again for some grated cheese on the side. This guy should be grateful people are choking this down with a Snapple T! If I didn’t have a Snapple to rinse down with I would have thrown both sandwiches in the GARBAGE. Hey Anthony …people are coming to your shop because the sandwich WAS good , what happened? TAKE PRIDE IN YOUR BUSINESS and enough with the CASHING IN on the hypefrom Midwest and Florida hipsters who never ate a good vodka parm or chicken parm…CMON.Any deli or pizzeria would have blown todays sandwiches away. CMON GUYS#DON’T BELIEVE THE HYPE
I ordered the chopped cheese. I was expecting it to be amazing for the price (traditionally cheap and delicious sandwich). The cheese wasn’t even melted. Not the end of the world, but for $15 for a chopped cheese, it better be on point.
If you love sandwiches ? and are in the area this is definitely worth a stop. The place lives and breathes Brooklyn Italian-American tradition.It can get busy so be prepared for a short wait and maybe even some queuing.The chicken cutlets are amazing, super savory. Marios Special is a good option.
I was around the area and decided to try these sandwiches, and I'm so glad I stopped by to buy one. I can't wait to go back to Brooklyn and have this again! The service was fast only waited 10 mins for two sandwiches which is reasonable because they make everything fresh.