started off mot so good. There was a line outside which was unnecessary because it wasn't even crowded inside.
The best seafood fast service
When heading to Tony's bring cash,, they are a CASH ONLY establishment. Tony's Pier is great for casual dining on City Island. The food is great! Offerings are fried or broiled. The drinks are excellent. Prices are good for the quality and quantity of food. Indoor and outdoor seating. Lines are normal but move quickly and are organized. Food is so good, I will wait!?. My favorite casual dining on the island.
Good seafood and shrimp and you can sit outside as well beautiful view
Best fried shrimp I had on City Island. Additionally the most welcoming staff. The restaurant is wheelchair-accessible and ensured we were served promptly and seated comfortably. Fantastic service.
I went this afternoon for Valentines Lunch. The shrimp breading was orange and the taste was completely different ( not bad but not delicious like it use to be) they were also smaller. WTH? Is it under New Management? I bypassed all the other Restaurants because this was the SPOT at one point! and they were the best .... sadly now i can say its the worst!
I went on February 21st, 2022, I saw Jimmy's Reef was closed, saw Tony's across the street and said let me try it, plus it was my Birthday. They have plenty of parking, there were young ladies taking pictures of themselves in front of the murals on the building. The security guard directed peopleto where the line was to order food. I ordered Whiting and chips. While waiting for my food I went to the bar and ordered a Strawberry margarita. Overall, drinks were good, food needs seasonings, so you better get alot of hot sauce and tartar sauce for the taste. The fish was fresh smelled like it just came out of the sea.
the view of the water. they have out door dining
I went this afternoon for Valentines Lunch. The shrimp breading was orange and the taste was completely different ( not bad but not delicious like it use to be) they were also smaller. WTH? Is it under New Management? I bypassed all the other Restaurants because this was the SPOT at one point! and they were the best .... sadly now i can say its the worst!
Went for lunch. Fried shrimp and fries, fried lobster tails and shrimp. Feeds three ppl. Fresh n good. Enjoyed the trip and stay. Nothing fancy or special. No tourists. Nice start for walking around town.