On the water…generous portions of expertly cooked seafood. Attentive and hardworking staff.
A very special 95th birthday celebration, made even more special by Owner Marie and her amazing staff. Cannot thank you enough. The Birthday Girl has been coming to this spot for lobster for 70 years! We rang in her latest trip around the sun with a 2 pounder and a margarita! It doesn’t get better. A thousand thanks yous!
Awesome service, staff, drinks, and food
The views are great
We wanted some good seafood and thought to drive out City Island. This place was one of the first places when you cross the bridge to City Island. The place looked a little slow around 4pm with plenty of seating. The service is attentive and food and drinks are brought out quickly. We tried the calamari for appetizer and it was fresh and tasty. We got a few dishes with lobster tails and some tasted fresh and one just tasted like it was sitting out of in the hot weather spoiled. We told our waiter and he said he will replace it for us. We had to wait additional 20 mins for the lobster tail to come out and just packed it to go. Service is good but food is hit or miss and I guess we missed.
Came by for early lunch the other day. Our wait staff named Earl was on point and took care of our table. He is professional and attentive to customers. We ordered the broiled seafood platter and broiled salmon. The food was cooked perfect. The drinks were great. The restaurants is a little pricey, but the food is well worth it.
I had the best time at the Lobster House to celebrate my Mother's Retirement. The customer service is 5 star. So so nice. The menu is somewhat expensive bit worth every dime. I definitely recommend but have your funds together. GOOD TIMES ?
Lovely family restaurant. Went fora late lunch on a Monday, its Amazing, how quickly this restaurant gets filled. However, the quality of the attention received on behalf of all the staff and the quality of the food is exceptional. Fresh, flavorful, great portion and presentation, it's a hidden gem.Place is ample, good music, clean. Valet parking service available. If you too city island this should be one of your destination, It's a must go 100%
My family and I come here frequently, on special occasions. We love the food here. The portions are HUGE! The food is always fresh. The servers are very friendly and attentive. The service is quick. And the restaurant itself is very big. It's right by the water so there's a gorgeous background at majority of the seating areas. Overall, this is hands down my favorite seafood restaurant.
This is an amazing restaurant, I went to eat a lobster and the food and the experience was amazing, the food was fresh and delicious and on time, the waiter Antonio was amazing as well, I was in the same table that Ricardo Arjonas ate 3 years ago, I recommended the restaurant 100% the treatment from Antonio was the best, I will come back to this place definitely…..