Great service 4/30/22 very busy up beat nice friendly service,From the hostess , it starts with her, she used very good judge ment by seating a senior with a cane before myself and my husband .our waitress was friendly and she kept checking in with us to let us know that she was on her way the bus boy was on his job i-around good experience it reminded me of how Arties used to be before the pandemic , my husband and I will be backI missed the warm bread and salad ?though. We expect it from Arties
Great meal as always. Cathy was the best. Roberto s desserts were off the hook. Only place I eat in City Island….. never disappointed. Great to see Spiro’s staff was amazing as usual. 10 stars
Where can I begin, does mediocre even begin to give you a sense. I chose Artie's over other City Island eateries expecting a better quality meal than Tony's or Sammy's but didn't get what I paid for. The clams oreganata needed more flavor, garlic and lots more oregano, I've made them better at home. The Manhattan clam chowder was probably the best part of the entire meal. The garlic bread resembled those 25 cent mini heros you get in the supermarket; it was small, dry, flavorless and just plain sucked! The frozen garlic breads are way better. I should've brought Texas toast in my pocket. Now for the meal. The Surf N Surf came out with an overcooked, rubbery lobster tail and a bland tasteless ensemble of what they called shrimp scampi. The red potatoes were the tastiest part of that dish. My dish was the broiled snow crab clusters with corn on the cob and french fries. It was adequate. The waitress was somewhat aloof and failed to refill my soda on several occasions but did remember to add each request to my bill. She needs to retire, I don't know if it was dementia or a lack of interest. In any event, you get the picture. For what I paid I could have eaten lobster and steak at the Capital Grill or the Palm. Enter at your own risk. I'll go elsewhere.
Great overall experience! We'll continue to visit here. The drinks, food and desserts are amazing. Our servers are always friendly and helpful.
Awesome experience! Great food,amazing atmosphere, super friendly and attentive server. Im definitely going back again.
Roberto our server was a great influence in helping us decide on what to order , he helped to make our visit to Artie's a special occasion , he was very knowledgeable about what was on the menu and he was friendly and approachable , my wife decided on the broiled lobster and I on the swordfish and we were far from disappointed Thank you Roberto .
This is an excellent restaurant with superior service frequented by the locals. For such a superior restaurant that serves creme brûlee to misspell mousse on their menues and not correct it is unforgivable and portends an indifferent Management. The crab cakes are to die for but rather small. They should offer an entree version of them. It is also time for them to update their menu and add more recent tastes of entree. The menu seems very 90s.
Very gracious hosting. We asked for a quiet table and they showed real genuine concern for getting us one. The food was very good. The service even better. Will gladly be back.
Food was great!!! The staff was real nice. Definitely recommend the fry jumbo shrimp
We went there the food was good, but when we arrived, we had to go up the stairs because the handicapped entrance had no sign or anything. When my grandma my mom and I wanted to leave through the handicapped entrance, we were told people were sitting there and there would be a draft so we had to go through the other door. I find this very unprofessional because we were told we could go through the handicapped exit and then were told we couldn't. Three of us had walkers out of the five people that went.