Kitty Mulligans Irish Pub

615 E Main St, Bay Shore - 11706
44 reviews
Irish Pub American
(631) 315-3571

had a little mishap with billing here and the owners made it right and showed me just what an upstanding great place this is. Thanks again Evelyn and Rich for helping me out with it... Great food and awesome atmosphere

Went to see a band play. They seated us at tables. Why would I want to sit down to see a band play? There was a very small area to dance. High-top tables would have worked better. Well, of course, the place cleared out early. And the bartender, Elizabeth, had a terrible attitude and it was very obvious she wasn't able to keep up. She didn't have the right personality to be a bartender. IMO Personality is key in that environment.

Ordered lunch (take out). Well done burgers were burnt to the point of being inedible (yes I get it, it’s well done but the burger meat shouldn’t crunch when bitten), fries were dry, the food tasted like it was cooked yesterday and thrown on grill to reheat. Salads were ok, lettuce was fresh out of the bag. Shepards pie was edible because there was no time to reorder food from another place.

We had a communion party at Kitty Mulligans. The private party room was perfect, beautifully set up when we arrived. The food was delicious , the cake that comes with each party package was so pretty made exactly the colors and filling we requested. Outstanding! Everyone had great time! The service was above and beyond. I highly recommend for private parties. We will be back!

Great Staff, Reasonable Drink Prices for Top Self Drinks, and live music with no cover charge on a Saturday.

smells so bad, toilets overflowing, drinks are not worth the price. and way too packed in. only cares about money. extreme under age drinking

Good atmosphere though the liquor is really watered down which made for some really weak drinks and not wanting to keep me there.

Great Atmosphere. Wonderful service!!

The place is definitely out of it's growing stage. It is a go to place for me and my friends now. Staff is great. Hope they don't hire a girl named Liz that was a bartender at swept away.

Great food,. Great staff,. Fun time Evelyn [ hope I spelled it right] brings Irish authensity to the bar abd a smile to your face.