Got the upside down it was ok sauce was kind of raw had to put tons of red pepper the guy said I wanted free pizza on Veterans Day and he was a cop in North Carolina and doesn’t forget a face and I catered an order too and wanted it for free haven’t catered an order since my sons communion 5 years ago and it wasn’t here very weird experience anyway the last owners had this place hopping
Horrible have been going there for 25 years the old owners were like Family John, Vinny and Maria were the best. Food now is the worst had pasta with olive oil and garlic tasted like dishwater pasta hard my friend had manicotti pasta hard. Previous time ordered chicken franchises got piccata. Wine glasses filthy don’t go you will only be disappointed
Disappointed..from bad to worse..last week pizza Margarita..today pizza joes special..everything lasted horrible
I wish when the last owner sold he would pass on all the recipes. It’s not the same taste. old recipe was the best in the island. The garlic knots was a big disappointment I miss the The Chiefs from previous owners?
Tonight I ordered 3 slices of pizza and pasta. They only gave me 1 slice of pizza when I asked for 3, and the pasta was over cooked. The pizza itself wasn’t good, and the food isn’t the same. I wish the old owners were back. I miss Joe’s Pizza!
Ever since the old owners sold this place it has changed. My family and I have been going here since 1998. When we heard they sold we were sad but John (one of the previous owners) said not to worry the new owners wouldn't change a thing. And well that was a lie. The garlic nuts which were my favorite and no other on the island compared are no longer the same. They are visibly different and taste different as well. The pizza doesn't taste the same either. And 95% of the original old staff is no longer there. Honestly just wish I could have one last bite of the old original recipes ?
The food was good recommend anybody to go there service is nice clean area nice place to take your family
Ok, someone tell me where do I go to satisfy my lasagna addiction now. I know the world is crazy trying to regroup after the pandemic but why did they have to kill my lasagna? Let me be the first to say change the recipe back.#freethelasagna
Joe's Pizza & Pasta has been our go to place for 30+ yrs. I can't believe how much the quality of food and service has declined. Our appetizers came out AFTER our meal and the server must have thought this was typical as she didn't say anything about it. The quality of the food is not the same. Shrimp Scampi somehow tastes exactly like Shrimp Fracese. Sad because, I won't be coming back and that makes me aad.
Not good after new owners, it was one of the best Pizzeria in Bay Shore, will not buy from there again.