Cherry's On The Bay

158 Bayview Walk, Bay Shore - 11782
113 reviews
Gay Bar Cocktail Bar
(631) 597-7859

We love Cherrys! Good drinks! Very nice Bartenders, like Tood and the boys from the 4th! Had a blast! And Sue plays great music!!

A really fun place with drag shows and dancing at night. Food is so so but the waiter was very nice, I'd come back, just not for the food.

Pretty low quality bar food. Insane New York prices and loud obnoxious locals who think their moral high ground is something to stand on, when it's really just moral decay.

I guess ill start with the performance piece. The shows I went to here were fun to watch and even though it was about giving out money, I still enjoyed myself. Next the staff. The wait staff was very nice but they seemed so fast to move from table to table, it could be because it was getting very crowded and I felt like maybe they were overwhelmed by it all. But my main reason why I'm giving it 3 stars is because the food was just ok but then again it is more like "bar food" that they sell there so I can see how it wouldn't be like an actual restaurant like quality. The drinks were kind of small but did pack a good punch. Then there was the set up of it. The show to the stage which was a bit strange to me but I guess when you have a limited amount of space, I guess that's how it had to be. The bathrooms there too were extremely small but like I said, also not their choice given the size of the place. I wish they did have more space. All in all, would I go back? Hell yes! I had alot of fun. This was my first trip to Fire island ever and I can honestly say that I felt like I was in a different planet where I didn't feel like I was being judged or criticized and I appreciated that feeling. So much love within the community.

Had a great time at the restaurant staff could not be better. Jacquelyn took great care of us. We all had the Fried chicken which was great. Good food, great view, what more could you ask.

This is the spot for a good sit down and drag queen shows.

Cherry’s is a royal drag palace! Genuinely great burger, come for world class drag or dancing or people watching, or a drink or meal on the bay. Everyone who works here is a delight of one sort or another :)

Amazing food, entertainment, and drinks! A highlight of Fire Island

Drag, drinks and summer fun. Always a good time at Cherry's! I'm especially fond of the mudslide :-)

Had a great time. So much fun