My Tomato Pie

3055 Niagara Falls Blvd, Amherst - 14228
202 reviews
Italian Pizza Vegetarian
(716) 260-1043

food is very good, BUT Portions are quite large for one person. Most of the pasta entrees ive had are very DRY & need more sauce to coat all the pasta underneath and make it taste like something other than bland pasta.. It would be helpful to toss the pasta in the sauce, then put the rest of the toppings over the pasta.. Id prefer a handful less pasta and a half ladle of extra sauce so there's more flavor. I usually order extra sauce , most recently was given and charged for a side of extra sauce that I didnt want or order.. It got launched in the trash , no room to keep it , & I didnt want that much more sauce.. Put the sauce in the pasta and id be goodMy concern with the large portions is that I dont have much room in the fridge to store leftovers & have no way to re heat the food.. when this happens the food I cant eat or store gets launched .. id be better with out food for 3 that I have to waste

Excellent food. Menu has a lot to offer. Parking lot has plenty of room to park. Have always gotten a seat without any wait time. Food comes out quite quickly. Staff incredibly nice and attentive.Have also been there for a baby shower and the staff were wonderful.They work with the WNY Alzheimer's Chapter and have donated proceeds from sales to their campaign annually.

Recently hosted a rehearsal dinner in the little banquet room. The food was outstanding and the service was fantastic. AND, the price was very reasonable. I would recommend to anyone holding an intimate banquet.

I place an online order with this place for pick up. they charge my credit card, send me an email confirming my order. then send a text telling me my food is ready.When i arrive to pick up my order the restaurant is closed!I get a call the next day basically saying - ooops we screwed up and we'll refund your credit card. No formal apology from anybody. CLASSLESS

I have been here several times with friends. The food is simply fantastic. The servers are wonderful and friendly. I love this place.

Called on Mothers day and was on hold for 16 minutes while we drove there. Walked in and we were still on hold and talked to lady at counter taking orders and there was no apoligy. Ordered a pie and waited 20 minutes in the parking lot, went in to get it and the order was wrong. Again, no apoligy, was told they would make another one so sat in the car for another 20 minutes with no discount or apoligies. Sent complaint to a manager and after all this, they wanted more detail. Obviously, even the ,anagement lacks customer service qualities. Took and hour to get a single pie and the management sends a request for more detail.Are you serious. Clowns and aholes run this place.

I place an online order with this place for pick up. they charge my credit card, send me an email confirming my order. then send a text telling me my food is ready. When i arrive to pick up my order the restaurant is closed! I get a call the next day basically saying - ooops we screwed up and we'll refund your credit card. No formal apology from anybody. CLASSLESS

We called ahead to reserve a space for a large group from out of state. They were able to accommodate us as well as a last minute addition. The staff were wonderful and absolutely lovely to have wait on us. The food was delicious! Everyone in our group found something they liked!

Top notch wait staff! My Tomato Pie is always able to fit our family in when other restaurants cannot. Food is delicious too. I 100% recommend!

Excellent friendly service and delicious food. We had pizza bread and a chicken finger calzone.