Traveled to the area from out of state. I called to make sure they could deliver to a hotel before I asked our group what they wanted. They said they could deliver it, but I would have to order it right then, I couldn't call them back in 5 minutes. Oh well! No business from us!
Large cheese, Extra sauce, well done is perfection. Grew up eating the other location on Delaware and I’m happy to report this one is just as consistent and delicious. Great Buffalo style pie.
Look at the execution of this pie! Was every bit as good as it looked. As it always is. Love it.
I got a pizza here last night, 7/15, and it gets 5 starts for how yummy it looked!! Unfortunately, that’s all it had going it for it. Seems to really lack seasoning… taste wasn’t all there…. And there was a black hair on my pizza that didn’t belong to anyone in my house…. Which turned me off and I couldn’t eat anymore ?…. I get it that that can happen, but was quite disappointed.
Knowing that wings are a big deal here in Buffalo, I’ll say that Mattina’s has THE best BBQ wings in the greater Buffalo area.Pizza is yummy as well, though, my hubby prefers to crisp the crust in the oven or on the stove.One of the few places we always return to :)
I'm a pizza connoisseur and this is probably the best pizza in the area. Good sauce and pep. Not much of a crust but it works. Slices are big enough where their lunch deal that includes 2 slices is too much. So $3.50 for a slice is a cheap meal. Good customer service as well. And I'll note the consistency of the pizza is appreciated as well since their competitor I used to enjoy on Hopkins Rd is just too hit or miss depending on who's working that day
Mat 18th 2022 Very good. Pizza was nicely cooked, good amount of sauce on under the cheese. Wings were saucy like I asked for. Thanks For making it right!
Stopped in for lunch from out of town and I made the right choice. The gentleman working the front was extremely helpful and helped me land on the lunch special of two slices and a soda for only $8. Pizza was amazing and I certainly will be coming back here again!
Simply incredible. The tomato sauce lends itself to a sweetness that creates a synergy with the cheese and dough that does not let anything left to be desired. Something to write home about. A special place, to say the least.
Wanted to order 3 half pizzas/ 1 and a half pizzas aka small pizzas... we were told they don't do half pizzas because they are too busy.How can you just not make a size that you list on your menu and force people to buy a larger size?