Anderson's Frozen Custard

2369 Niagara Falls Blvd, Amherst - 14228
190 reviews
Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Burgers Ice Cream Shop
(716) 691-8970

We love Anderson's. I haven't been to one in years since I moved away. I was just shocked by how expensive it was.

The ice cream cake had a very different and eye catching design! It also tasted very good! My first time buying an ice cream cake from Anderson’s; I’ll definitely be back!

Always visit here. They have ice cream and food. Never tried the drive thru. Got a root beer milkshake, this was made with root beer syrup not from the fountain and the Choco Peanut Butter Passion. Lots of indoor and outdoor seating. Multiple registers to place order. Variety of food, drinks and ice cream flavors. Employees are nice and quick.

Only had soft serve ice cream, so I can't comment on anything else. Small cone was on what I would have considered a baby cone, and quantity was equivalent to that as well. Price was in line with small cone prices at other shops. Quality was very good, but overall I was disappointed. Service was OK. 4 stars is hoping that the food continues to be above average.

The ice creams are ok. The bubble gum flavor had some gum pieces that are very hard to chew. The Oreo ice cream had tons of cookies which was nice, but the one with pretzels just a couple of pieces and the ice cream didn’t taste like much.

Cant go wrong! I've been to this Anderson's and the one in Williamsville on Main St. Always delicious food and custard/ice cream with good service. I associate this restaurant with Beef on Weck and Sahlen's hot dogs but the chicken tenders were just as good.

Good food with good variety. Excellent service and friendly people.

Love Andersons! Commonality for our family to drive by the river and get frozen custard afterwards. Pleasant surprise to learn custard is half-off on snow days. Yum!

Casual, indoor seating! Ice cream is very good and generous portions. The menu has other things, but I genuinely couldn't name anything.Not from the area?What existed before "wings"?Beef on Weck...?Get au jus, in the Kimelweck bun (weck locally) and Horseradish on the side...Notice - white bread and gravy is never part of this sandwich!Don't forget the Curly Fries... these are not the "expedited nutrition" curly fries you might be familiar with!Enjoy! ??

Food is delicious. Hate that they are closed on Sundays...need one further north on the Blvd in Niagara falls