I Love New York Pizza

1825 Central Ave, Albany - 12205
154 reviews
Pizza
(518) 452-9400

Been going here for over 10 years, and it's not the same. Had a 6-7 year stretch where I was coming out to Colonie consistently, then the last couple of years the company I work for didn't pick up anything, but now we're back.The pizza used to be great, now, it's OK. Floppy, a little on the greasy side, so the crust isn't crisp, it's soft. You don't get a reasonably "stiff" piece of pizza, it sags.Also, the sausage topping used to be my favorite, but I swear, in the last couple of years, at some point, they changed it, it's not as good.Haven't had the wings in a while, but they used to be fantastic, hoping they they still are, as I'm going to grab some in the coming days.It's edible and priced in line with everyone else, but it's no longer a place I look forward to going to, which stinks, cuz it was so good years ago.

I order special- 12 cut pie and 20 wings with a 2 liter soda. Wings requested were garlic parm mixed with bbq. Wing were soaked in oil clumps of bbq sauce. My order was picked up at 7pm and I had mu 2 young children with meI called the restaurant and was advised they closed at 9pm. My husband got off of work a little later so we missed it that night. The next day we were rudely advised that the order van not be changed because the register had been closed out. I advised her if my young children and my husband working late and was blatantly told "it's not my problem". Finally she agreed if I returned the wings, she would make a new order. My husband had yhr wings that we didn't touch and we were refused again because I did not have them. I have order from them countless time but NEVER AGAIN. $43 down the drain because the pizza was gross but I had already given to my children because it was supposed to be dinner. Don't waste your time. Whoever is there now is simple RUDE and does not deserve an establishment in my neighborhood.

My favorite pizza place. I love going to get the veggie pizza and the chocolate mousse cake .? Friendly staff clean set up A+

Pizza is always good, however I'm disabled and on various meds. Sometimes I get caught short and need to use a rest room. I asked today and was told that I could not use it. I was the only one in the store at the time. A little decency on the part of your employee would have been appreciated. I have been to your shop many times over the years and always leave a tip. I was very disappointed, as I was really in need.

Food was great. My 8 year old brother enjoyed it so much he ate 6 slices of pizza.. The customer service was great and they followed all request.

Waited an hour and a half for the order. Pizza is ice cold. Almost no sauce. I'll have to microwave this to even eat it. Not good. Wings have almost no sauce on them but the bag is drenched in buffalo sauce and made a mess. Cheesecake was thrown in a container and is messed up. Awful. First and last time ordering here!!! $50 for this smfh.

Pizza is always good there. They've been in operation at that location for 2 decades.

messed up my order again normally I let it go but when I called I was told lied then hung up on after 12 years or doing business I will never order again

The pizza was horrible the last two delivery orders. Tonight it was burnt to where it was impossible to chew. I called the store. A woman answered and said her husband makes it and if I don’t like it don’t order there anymore then hung up on me. This is the same lady that I had a bad experience for previously when ordering for my church and she’ rude…nasty attitude. She won’t have to worry about us ordering again.

Pizza is good, place could use some updating but if you don't mind that then try the chicken parm or ziti slices. Or don't. I don't really care.