Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings

1600 Route 23 North, Wayne - 07470
183 reviews
Pizza Italian American
(973) 872-2625

Love this place. The best Happy Hour of all time and the best Bartender of all time. I’m not sure what her name is, but I think it is Melisssa. She works Monday to Friday from 3 p.m. to close and some full days. She is awesome and everyone Loves her. A lot of regular Customers come just to interact with her. She has a bright Future with your Company. She should be commended.

Came here for the first time and left disappointed. Service was not great, food was bland and entrees came out at different times. Was expecting to get our appetizer first but my husbands entree came out before and then the appetizer. While both my daughters and I waited 30 min for our entrees. During that time the server barely interacted with us. When asked why entrees did not come out together I was told they bring food out when it’s prepped. I’ve worked in the food Industry and know that appetizers are put in first and then the entrees to ensure everyone gets their foods at the same times.Definitely will not be coming back. Our experience was all but positive from beginning to end.

We had a huge soccer party and Isaac was amazing. He had to deal with a lot of screaming girls and was so patient. The food was on point and quick.

Get the Marino eggplant pie ! You won’t be disappointed. Been coming here for years. Always good. Service tonight left a little to be desired but the awesome food makes up for it.

Sat at the bar for lunch today and Kerri the bartender was absolutely the best made the whole experience worth it to come in for lunch great people person

Don’t waste your time. Both times we went to eat there, we stood waiting and waiting for someone to seat us. Obviously, they don’t have any sense of urgency!!

Barely attentive to my girlfriend and I and snubbed me when i was about to ask question . Gave us the cold shoulder pretty much the entire time. Never had an experience there like that before. You honestly deserve the 1 cent tip gave you.

This is one of my favorite places along with my fiance Kevin and Melissa are the best bartenders their drinks are on point all the time staff is very friendly

We love Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza. However, the last two times we went to the Wayne location we were disappointed.Tonight we went and were seated right away! Fantastic. It was 30 minutes before anyone came to our table to take our order. We waited for some time and no food. People who came in after us were served their pizza and wings. After practicing an enormous amount of grace (maybe they were short staffed), I asked the host to have our order changed to go. Again, we waited. Again, people who came in long after us were served their food. Finally, they came with our wings wrapped but no pizza. They blamed the ovens and said there was no charge. We appreciate that but I was left still wanting the pizza. We left and got pizza from another restaurant. Not quite the same.Prior to tonight, we were disappointed in the quality of the food. It was not nearly as good as it has been in the past.Again, we love Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza but we will try the Clifton location as the Wayne location has disappointed us. Here’s hoping.

Its my first time ordering from this restaurant and I ordered it for delivery and it came early and the pizza was delicious . Make sure to order the 16 inch because the 12 inch was small.