Despite the high star rating, the reviews talking about the soggy, slid pizzas are painfully true. I ordered a large with meatball and the cheese had piled up to one side bad enough that those slices had to be eaten with a fork. Even the intact slices were soggy + the cheese and sauce don't even seem as if they're 'attached' to the crust underneath. No idea what happened. I gave 2 stars because the meatballs were good and the overall flavor was okay. There is a lot of pizza choice in Toms River--please, do better!
Decided to give Schiano's another try after getting a sub par pizza a couple of years ago. We ordered an appetizer, salad with chicken and shrimp scampi over spaghetti for my husband. They delivered some sort of chicken dish instead of the scampi. When I called they said not to touch the incorrect entree and they would deliver the correct dinner right away. We live 5 minutes away, after 15 minutes I called and they said it was on the way. It took another 15 minutes for his food to arrive. They took the incorrect dinner back and never even offered us anything for our troubles. Never again, two strikes and you're out.
Absolutely terrible. Worst pie by far Soggy. Cheese fell right off. Bland. If I had to officially review this pie. Score= 0.8. The 0.8 comes from the garlic knots I got on the pizza????? Otherwise 0.1 all day long. What a shame.
Great pizza, friendly staff. Love this spot
Delicious! I've come in a few times for slices when I was working on the area and each time its been a great experience. Large slices with so many different toppings, the staff are friendly and it's a quick process. Ample seating and decent parking.
Oh. My. Lord.I got a chicken, bacon, ranch with buffalo sauce and garlic knots on top. The sheer size of this slice normally would be almost $4 for just a plain slice, but this whole thing with all the toppings ONLY cost $4! AND it came with dipping sauce for the garlic knots. OMFG it was heaven ??
The pizza tasted frozen and all of the cheese fell off. The blue cheese tasted unauthentic, like it came out of a bottle from shop rite. I have no clue what happened with this place. It used be authentic pizza that we raved about. It seems like covid made them cut some corners and destroyed their desire to make good homemade italian food.
Always great food. Ordered a small pie..got a pleasant surprise..free upgrade to a large.. written on the box!
Great Service for Take out, I have not been inside as of yet. The Pizza & Mozzarella Sticks were delicious.2/14= We ordered pies from here often never had a problem. Last night we ordered 2 shrimp parmigiana subs & 1 chicken cutlet parmesan sub it was delicious fresh bread, delivery men always friendly, courteous. We found our spot.Thank you.
About 3rd time ordering and was on the fence about ordering but it is closest. Once again the entire pie was burnt to a crisp. We could not eat it and threw it out. Not sure how they can take it out the oven and serve this. Unsure of the other food quality