Rita's Italian Ice & Frozen Custard

1687 Lakewood Rd, US-9, Toms River - 08755
63 reviews
Ice Cream Shop Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Shaved Ice
(848) 777-4827

The general manager is very sweet I spoke to her about an incidence she's very kind to me it is now about 5 Weeks Later I am sitting in the Rita's parking lot I'm sad to say my decision to come back here was wrong maybe when is employees here have a little respect for people and aren't under the age of 25 and know what respect is and know how to treat people I might come back but in till then I will go to another Rita's and I can now see why there's hardly anybody in the parking lot here used to be a nice place to come to...not anymore

$8 for a Sundae which is fine if they had sundae fixings to go on it. No hot fudge, no nuts, no pineapples. This was just ice cream with whipped cream. ?

Strawberry greatBut not alot of choices, short staff

Unbelievable downward slide in 2 years and I fully understand where the economy is. Looks like new owners and they changed the recipes to everything accommodating to one faith. Also prices went way up I used to bring my family of 4 here for 16-18 bucks now it’s for 2 people 18 bucks. Seriously I will email Rita’s headquarters about this

Redeemed my first day of spring free ice and it was delicious. The treat team provided great service and were extremely friendly. The juicy pear ice is the best ice they have there. You can’t go wrong with juicy pear.

Very poor service order a large sundae And was over charged $8.52 each it looked very small and the ice cream maker was spitting out little spouts of ice cream not sure why not

Excellent tasting frozen treats! Was my first experience at this chain and loved it.

Always love going to this Rita's. Staff was amazing, service was as expeditiously as possible, and ices were great as usual. Well worth the trip. Highly recommend!Emily, Angelina, Angel and Krystal…wish I could have given a bigger tip. KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK! ?

Tastes good but they were a bit special and didn't know what was flying

This Rita’s location is great. I really like the workers, Issa and ilonah. They’re the cutest sister sibling duo I’ve ever seen!