Okay so a single plain slice is $2.75, $1 more with toppings, but i mean sadly this is common now...$16 for a large pie though... that's a good price while most places are close to $21. Prices aside staff is friendly, place is clean. Pizza ranking is HIGH! Many types of slices available, crust and sauce are excellent, cheese is very good. Overall best in Toms River!
Ordered from here a lot I guess pre pandemic. Never any problems except wait times, which made sense because the pizza was amazing. I've stopped by and called during "business hours" and the place was vacant and no one ever answers the phone. No messages, no social presence. Judging from all the recent reviews this place turned a corner and has been going down hill since. Sad because it was so good and I didn't mind paying a little extra considering there's 20 pizza places within a mile of it.
Pizza is delicious! Staff is super friendly. I usually get delivery but I stopped in for food and was horrified when I looked up and saw the amount of dirt (mold?) on the ceiling. I would have given a 5 star but some may say I am too generous with 3 given this image I took.
I have tried most of the pizza in Toms River, Manchester and Brick and this is one of the best slices on my list now. I have become a big fan of Grandma and Margherita slices and the staff suggested I try the "Old Fashioned'. This slice had so much great flavor and great crispiness throughout! The toasted sesame seeds on the end crust really made it taste unique from other pizzas. Part of my pizza rating is, "Is it as good as you near the crust end as it tasted during the first few bites?"
Great pizza! one of the best I ever had. The staff were so nice and friendly, give them a try you will be disappointed
first time tried, square pizza looked good online but reality was that while the sauce was good it was swimming on top of the pie, crust was not cooked except on bottom and was extremely underdone, wife and I ate 2 slices and threw out the rest. 26.66 for a plain cheese pie incl tax. we'll stick with a sicilian from Positanos or Nino's.
I got the upside down pizza. It was really good. I must say I do not eat thick crusted pizza at all. I never liked it, and this was the first one that I liked. I was impressed. The sauce was good the cheese was really good and the dough was cooked to perfection; soft on the inside but had a bit of a crunch to the outside when I bit into it. We drove an hour for this pizza. I would do it again.
Very tasty pizza. There only reason I don't go more often is because they are so busy.
Ordered via Slice tonight. I live 6 miles away, well within their delivery area.After the order is put in, they call us -- they don't have garlic knots, but they do have garlic bread. Ok, cool, thanks for calling.Time goes by... Slice says it's out for delivery so we wait. And wait. And get worried.At 5:45 - 1hr 45min after ordering! - they call us to say we were "way out of their delivery range, we don't know how you were able to put an order in".Told us to pick it up ourselves, or cancel it via Slice.Wait, what? We're 6 miles away, you already called us once, AND you set it for delivery in the app... And it never left your restaurant?I don't know what's worse, the fact that this happened, or the that they're clearly lying about what happened to our order.Absolutely ruined our kids' dinner tonight. Handled terribly.Slice on the other hand was great to deal with, cancelled the order via chat in two minutes and issued a refund.
Within the 2 seconds we walked into the door one of the ladies behind the counter immediately asked us 3 time what we want with an attitude before we could even look at what they had to offer. We ordered got our drinks and not even 2 mins after sitting down, the lady looked at me and yelled um hello while flicking her wrist to come grab the food and giving us a dirty look, like us buying food from there was an inconvenience to her. The pizza was cold,after they placed it in the oven for what was probably about a minute and a half. The lady ringing us up was nice but the other one who I'm guessing might be the owner, as a regular employee would never get away with that attitude towards customers, was unbelievable rude. There are about 100 other pizzas placing around here, you should never treat paying customers like that. First and only time we'll ever be going there.