I've been meaning to write a review for quite a while. We typically order from Attilo's about once a week and this place is the best we've had in Toms River. We've done wraps, subs, and catering orders and it's all good. The only thing I'd mention is that delivery times can get a little crazy but they have a ton of orders I'm sure. We order online mostly and it gives you the approximate wait time so you'll have a good idea before you place an order. Long story short you can order from here with confidence.
Never tried this place but all the bad reviews on here are truly pathetic.This will be my new pizza spot & home since I'm right across the street. The good ratings out do the bad ratings. I've worked in pizza business for 20 years I know what to look for.I cannot wait to try this place & call it my home
After having a completely screwed up experience via doordash with Attilio's we proceeded to order straight through them and pick up. While picking up my order, I inquired if they delivered to my address, to which I was told yes and to bypass doordash entirely...Attilo's has the best pizza we have found in our area since moving here a few years ago. They are very accommodating and make any attempt to work with you.The customer service is fantastic, the owner is very nice and handles any issues immediately. I can't recommend them enough.
Chicken California…without the chicken….got their garlic knot meatball sliders too thank god. not worth calling to complain. Just won’t order again. 21 dollars plus tip. Looking forward to the next shop in there.
Their gluten Free food is AMAZING!!! I got the gf mozzarella sticks, pepperoni pizza, & tiramisu and i am a picky eater and all three things were really good...found my new favorite pizza place!!!
Nice place , good pizza ✌?
Very good food! The chicken parm with vodka sauce is delicious. Bread for subs is the best I’ve had!Staff is friendly and delivery time is accurate.I order usually once a week and grab a slice 2-3 days during the week.The chicken parm pizza and meatball pizza is my go to to order by the slice.
Ordered a large pie well done It was 12:00 in the afternoon, Told 20 minutes, Got there picked the pie up. Had a 6 minute ride home, opened the box to find a REHEATED slice pie in the box The cheese was YELLOW and the puddle of grease on the top was exquisite! I can’t believe they actually sent that out ! I even called them and they DID NOT EVEN DENY IT Here’s your fair warning That’s really a sucky way to run a business And I’m hoping Carlos sees this! Another longtime customer gone Since 1977
I am writing this review in regard to my catering order, which we all enjoyed yesterday- Sunday 12/26.I ordered the 5 tray package for $199.00 that feeds 10-12 people. I choose penne with vodka sauce, chicken murphy, sausage & peppers, roasted potatoes and the antipasto salad. They also included a bag of fresh baked bread.Everything was so delicious and the portions were more than enough for our family of 10.We were all raving about the food - each one of the dishes were so tasty and so delicious- yum yum.I would definitely order from Attilio’s in Toms River again . The ordering process was super easy and the food was ready at the exact time that I requested.Great job Attilio’s. You gained another customer for life.
Just moved to Toms River and have been looking for our go to pizza place. Definitely the best pie we’ve had! Cooked perfectly and great flavor, will be back soon!