Friendly, attentive and polite family restaurant with more than adequate seating if you want to dine-in. We've ordered, picked-up and eaten two of their pizzas several time ..., they were delicious. One can drive into the alley where there's an entry door to pick up your order and, there's plenty of parking behind the restaurant if you choose to dine-in.
I was here for a family gathering and sat in the small dining room area that they have. The food was great and the room was perfect for a little gathering.
Omg, best food ever!!! Go now, run!!! Hurry they get hella bogged down. Patron after patron, they can hardly keep up. But in a great way.
It was good pizza. Don't get me wrong. We had sausage and extra cheese pizza. I will say the sausage was crumbled and had tons of flavor. The rest was well done but nothing that completely "wow"ed me. Would I eat it again? Most definitely. But considering I live closer to something I consider better.....I just would probably default to that place instead. I am sure if I lived alot closer to this, this would be one of my standard pizza places.
5 different meals all were great. Pasta w/Mussels, chicken Frances,fried calamari, wings, garlic bread 2diff. Ways, garlic knots,and 2 other pasta/chicken.All we're perfect and delicious. Not the first time there, have had large party orders (30 people) and not disappointed. Eat in also. Clean and always friendly.
good eggplant and meatballs
We have family in the area and I purposely miss a meal when I know we're going to rockaway so that we can order from Anthony's! This place is a landmark in town and the staff are amazing! Food is fantastic! You will not be disappointed in quality, portion size, price! Calzones are sized to feed a small army and the pizzas are amazing.
This restaurant needs to work on their timing. Called in an order and arrived when they said it would be ready, ended up standing there for half an hour! Only to receive an ice cold pie and cold Buffalo wings with no sauce on them! Definitely would not recommend this place.
Omg it was amazing! I'm from Florida but, my fiance is from Jersey. He brought me there to experience authentic pizza! So good!
This place ranked 24 out of 25 on my Google search for best Pizza in NJ. I didn't think that it was good Pizza .... bottom has a burnt taste that overpowers the slice of pizza. 3 stars is generous.