So happy we found Otto and his brother here! If you are from the area then you know that Otto & his brother basically did all the cooking when Rodolfos in south plainfield was owned previously by Frank & Vinny. Ottos pizza is great, crust has a good taste and sauce as well, generous with cheese and toppings and minimal flop. Also ordered antipasto salad that was fresh also ordered a large pepperoni roll/Stromboli, Wow it was enough for 3 meals and tasted so good! Best part is they deliver to south plainfield piscataway and plainfield. Will be our new go to pizza and basic pasta dinner place. Decent price & quantity. Definitely a must try for everyone!
Their cheesesteak and buffalo chicken pizza are both great!!! So happy I ordered from them.
Ordered here based on reviews. Pizza was cold, crust was chewy. Probably the most dry, unseasoned pasta I’ve ever had. My daughter enjoyed her pasta Alfredo.
I checked this place out after the reviews went above my go to places in surrounding towns. The last few weeks I've bounced around the menu trying as much as I could. Pizza is AMAZING. Entrees are fantastic!. Hot and cold subs, delicious. Even desserts, wow. I haven't had anything I didn't like. The portions are filling, which few places can match anymore. Give them a try.
I've had the pizza and it was perfect! chicken bacon ranch I believe. and a plain slice.today I ordered the chicken parm w/ ziti and it was also PERFECT. the sauce is nicely seasoned and the chicken cooked nicely. the side salad the came with it was fresh and dressed nicely ?.I'm glad we finally have a GOOD pizza place in the area. I'll definitely be back.
By far the Best pizza in the area! I’ve lived in South Plainfield for over 30 years and this is my new and only spot! I’ve been eating here 2-3 times a week since they opened and haven’t been disappointed once. The Pizza is Amazing. Whether it be just a plain slice or specialty slice(Buffalo chicken) my favorite. The hot and cold subs are traditionally made and are out of this world! This place is a hidden gem and definitely will be on NJ TOP 100 pizzerias very soon. One last thing I will mention is that the customer service is impeccable. Always friendly, professional and prompt. 5/5 in every aspect.
Great pizza! Very authentic New-York style! The cheese and toppings are of high quality and the crust is on point. The staff is very friendly. Highly recommended!
The best pizza place in the area.
This restaurant has excellent tasting food! The pizza is delicious and so are their toppings, especially the sausage. The pizza crust is cooked perfectly! I also tried the mozzarella sticks and the linguine with vodka sauce. I definitely recommend this restaurant!
This is my go to pizza joint. I grew up locally and the owner of Otto's used to work around the corner at a pizzeria, I relive my youth with every bite. They make amazing pizza, pasta and sandwiches, highly recommend!