On Saturday the 10th I asked why I paid more for a 35$ margarita pie instead of a 25$ cheese pizza? Could you spare any MORE of the TWO other MAIN ingredients that you charged extra for?? And the other was a pepperoni pie which tasted like a burned piece of bread, because IT WAS BURNED on the bottom. I get it this is the boardwalk, but this is an embarrassment when the help replies “well thats the way a margarita pie is.” When the customers are old enough to be their parents but are treated like they don’t know what they ordered. I just know where I’m NOT getting more boardwalk pizza
Literally the best pizza I’ve had on the boardwalk, and probably the best pizza I’ve had in years. Perfect amount of flop and crunch, which is perfectly balanced with a superb sauce-to-cheese ratio.Gianluca is the pie creator of the night. If you come here, make sure the one making your pizza is wearing a back-facing ball cap, and it’ll be worth every penny.
Had a great slice! Then my family bought pizza from another place (not naming names…no negativity here), and a nice man from Gigi’s brought us a free slice to prove his was better. FREE! And the other 5 taste tested…and guess what…GIGI’s was better!
We got a funnel cake at a place next door and saw a guy eating a tasty looking sicilian slice from this place. We decided to get a pie to take home.$25 for a pizza they refer to as a “whole pie”. It’s a regular large cheese pizza. For $25. RIP my wallet. Not Sicilian style and no extra toppings (which were an additional $4 each topping). Won’t be going back.
I wait all year to see Deven and his wonderful personality! He always makes us feel welcomed and like family! We have said this from the beginning......."GiGi NY Pizza IS the BEST Pizza on the boardwalk!!!
Amazing pie. Sicilian fresh out of the oven. Great slices. Certainly a must try at the boardwalk. Won't regret it