Krispy Pizza

50 College Ave, New Brunswick - 08901
138 reviews
Pizza
(732) 658-3800

I love this pizza. Best crust I’ve ever had.

Not the same krispy pizza as Brooklyn’s or freehold location. We got the penne vodka pie and it was not that good. The crust/dough didn’t seem authentic and it had SESAME seeds on the entire crust. Usually crust is the best part of the pie. Idk why they put sesame seeds on it.

My first time at Krispy pizza?. My friend and I were super tired and hungry post an exam that went horrible :(We tried the garlic knots, Margarita slice and the veggie pesto slice.The garlic knots were super yummy and so was the margarita slice.Pesto Slice was a little oily.The slice crusts are super crunchy and crispy making them different and yummy from the other pizza places.Overall a really good place.

We used get pizza from Krispy on 13th avenue in the 80's and 90's lived on the corner and that was a great pizza !!We moved to NJ and tried the pizza in New Brunswick cause it was Krispys! and sorry but it was horrible and we bought two different square pies trio and grandma.. What's most disappointing I had friends over and I kept saying wait till you taste Krispy Pizza. I was embarrassed when I saw the expression on my friends face ...Just being honest here not good at all....

Good experiences with each order, be it pickup, delivery, or ordering when I get there. Appetizers especially never fail to disappoint. The staff and delivery driver excel at their jobs in every aspect. My only regret is not coming here sooner.- Sanjit

The pizza was good, but the staff was rude to me for not “ordering my pizza the right way.” I’m a customer and I gave a tip, it is not my responsibility to automatically know how your ordering system works, especially never having gone there before. Usually when you go to a cashier and tell them what you want and pay, they are able to communicate with other staff so you can get your job done, but I guess not in this case. I don’t even know if I’ll go back because of the snarky comments that one of the guys there said to me. Seriously, I’m a stressed out college student and all I need is some random pizza guy who looks like an understudy for a Jersey Shore cast member yelling at me for literally no reason. If you’re reading this, calm down and chill out. You don’t need to pick on random people to try to make yourself feel better because you couldn’t make it on Jersey Shore.edit: i was making a joke lol. I didn’t see a sign anywhere and they could have just let me know in a normal tone that i needed to let them know. The man there was very disrespectful, so you believing your staff is courteous does not mean anything because I clearly had a bad experience. As far as you being “surprised,” I’m surprised because there are other comments about certain staff’s behavior, so it’s surprising that you would be surprised. Invalidating a customers feelings because you wanna look better is not the best way to go. oh and it wasn’t busy at the time, like at all.

Truly a great pizza place. Employees are always friendly, even when it is a bit busy. I’ve been coming here for years, but have recently become sort of a regular and they know me. I order two slices of the fat Krisp with extra sauce. Really good slice because it captures the fat sandwich vibe in pizza form. Their other pies are also very tasty. Their sauces (both vodka and regular) are very good. The sesame seeds on the vodka pie crust is something I never knew I wanted. A few days ago it looked like they were training some new employees and the guy didn’t know me and forgot to put the extra sauce on my regular order. I wasn’t going to say anything because I don’t like to complain (and the slice w/o the extra sauce is still great), but one of the employees that knew me noticed and pulled it off the counter and told him “don’t skimp him his sauce, he’s a loyal customer.” I’ve worked in both retail and food service and have pretty much seen it all when it comes to good and terrible customer service. This is excellent service.

Great place to get pizza. Great atmosphere. You walk in and you can just tell by the way the staff is that they make a good pie. Good balance between the toppings and sauce and cheeses. Only thing I don't like is the delivery service is lacking. Who ever the delivery guy is should focus on actually delivering per the customers instructions for delivery address

CUSTOMER SERVICE WAS AMAZING!!THE STAFF IS VERY FUNNY AND VERY NICE.THE BBQ CHICKEN PIZZA IS OUT OF THIS WORLD.SO DELICIOUS AND COOKED TO PERFECTION. 10/10.

I went to the Krispy's in Old Bridge for the first time when I met my wife (her and her family had been going to that location for years). When we got married, we moved to New Brunswick and couldn't believe when a Krispy Pizza opened a few blocks from where we live!Needless to say, we felt right at home. From the pizza. to the wings, to the service, Krispy's is our go-to Pizza spot. Our favorite is the Grandma Pie - always delicious! In fact, when it was overcooked one time, we called the store and they immediately offered us a replacement.We hope Krispy's sticks around in New Brunswick for a very long time!