Milk Sugar Love Creamery & Bakeshop

19 McWilliams Pl, Jersey City - 07302
229 reviews
Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Food Trucks
(551) 277-8252

Unique flavors, their flagship lemon olive is oh so good. The texture is not as thick as some other places like Jeni’s. Owner is rude/shitty but good ice cream I guess

First time customer. Staff was very friendly. Their midnight cocoa was so delicious. So many interesting flavor combinations. Will definitely stop by anytime I’m in the neighborhood and try a new flavor.

I went for the first time on Memorial Day 2022 in a group of 7. I loved the ice cream flavors they had, wish they had a vegan option everyday though. The reason I'm giving 3 stars is because of the very rude employee working that day - not friendly at all and practically scowling when asked for paper napkins. It was 90°F+ that day so ice cream was melting quite fast and to get an attitude over napkins is ridiculous. There were 7 of us and she gave a couple of napkins - when we went back in to ask for more, she treated us like we were asking for free ice cream. I'd love to come back for the delicious ice cream but I'm not sure if it's worth it.

We got a mini celebration ice cream cake for $12.5 + tax. It was premade and prepackaged, you just need to grab from the freezer and pay. It was a chunk of vanilla ice cream with 4 frosting swirls on the top, and decorated with sprinkles. I don't like the taste of sprinkles, yet that's the layer that you have to eat first because the rest of the thing was still frozen. Ice cream was good. I thought there would be a layer of cake or crust at the bottom to make it more of a "cake", but there wasn't.It was a cute thing to get for celebration, but not for a casual moment in the park. We'll stick to the normal menu for our next stroll.

Long wait, but the ice cream was decent. Very trendy spot, they really lean into the unconventional flavor options. My ice cream was a tad soft for my taste, it melted immediately. Staff was nice at least.

The ice cream is just okay. But the service is incredibly slow. So slow that it is never worth going. It should not take 5+ minutes to scoop for each customer. I keep going back thinking it will be different the next time around, but I always end up having to wait a crazy amount of time even if I am next in line. They claim it is because they are “short staffed”, but every staff member I have seen just scoops at a snail’s pace.

I will definitely be back for more Earl gray fudge ice cream!

Unique ice cream flavors and seasonal options

Finally tried this place out! They only allow one family in the store to order. It wasn't bad. The location is pretty small.Their flavors are pretty unique. I ordered the guava cheesecake and earl gray fudge. It was pretty yummy!! My daughter and hubby got the caramel (can't remember the name of it). I tried it and it was pretty good. My 3 year old had the vanilla bean and did not share....ate the whole thing on his own. The ice creams all taste fresh and are spot on with flavor. I would say the only bad part is the price for the serving that you get. However. It is a unique flavor.... I don't think I would troop all the way to Jersey City for this again, but it was a tasty treat.

This place is great. They have handmade cones (Pink vanilla, birthday cake, red velvet, and dark chocolate), ice cream, cookies, bakery bars, macaroons, and cupcakes. They have great prices and their stuff taste amazing. The staff was nice and the place was clean. I would highly recommend going here.