Liberty Bar

111 Montgomery St, Jersey City - 07302
317 reviews
American Steak House
(201) 333-3633

Awesome cocktails and service. We went for brunch and the steak and eggs were over cooked but still tasty.

Food was great! Service was great!

Great for date night !! We are coming back to explore the menu

Was super disappointed in my experience here. We came in for our anniversary and it did not feel special at all. The service was slow, we were bought out the incorrect food and my drink was taken away from me before I finished it. For the price I would have expected much better and I will not be returning.

I loved every single moment of our experience at Liberty Prime. It was my first time there and the service was incredible and the food was outstanding! I will absolutely be back.

Our steaks were way overcooked, and so was our appetizer. Not edible.

The service was wonderful and the food was outstanding. My partner and I could not stop raving about how tender the steak was. We went for Jersey City restaurant week (and also my birthday). We got complimentary champagne which was such a nice touch. Although I wasn't a fan of the chef selection dessert (sorbet), we had a great time and look forward to going back.

Only 2 tables with customers and service was still terrible

Will never be back. The service was atrocious—we were told there were no spaces in the restaurant when we arrived, but there were open reservations on OpenTable every 15 minutes. If you aren’t dressed like you are new money, they’ll try to seat you at the lousy bar or the upstairs, out of view like mad Bertha from Jane Eyre. Food was terrible. Steak tasted like overcooked rump roast. We asked for medium rare, and it came to us so dry and hard it was inedible. They made up for it by drowning it in gravy. The pricing is also funny. They will also scrounge you with fees — 3% credit card charge. Credit card required to reserve. Honestly, unless you enjoy spending money to be insulted and fed inedible food, head out to Kitchen Step for a way better steak and impeccable service.

We went in for restaurant week. First courses were great (French onion soup and the nueske bacon). We each ordered the New York strip for the main to be cooked medium. Both of them came out incredibly over cooked and very tough. Was certainly cooked well done. Was very disappointing. Cocktails were good and they gave us each a glass of champagne on the house. Service is good and very professional. Steak experience was a major let down though for both of us.