Benny freaking Tudinos, let's start with service, Tammy and pizza chef Alan are the best. Excellent service, treat you like family, felt like I was in my Ma's kitchen BSing with my cousins. Next, pizza! OMG! Listen I live in Chicago, this was hard. But let's not exaggerate and say this was the best pizza I had (because you know we do it better in Chicago), BUTTTT I'll say this was the BEST thin crust pizza I ever had. The slices were bigger than most newborn babies, I didn't finish. This was a food challenge I lost. This was the most ma and pa pizzeria I ever been to that backs their slice. Just go, you won't regret it. Ciao. Also I even bought a shirt to brag back at home.
Great pizza, but make sure you are hungry.As I am sure you each slice is the size of 2 or 3 slices elsewhere.Got slices to go with pepperoni on inexpensive and sausage on another. I split them and it was enough for two.Definitely recommend this place.
Benny freaking Tudinos, let's start with service, Tammy and pizza chef Alan are the best. Excellent service, treat you like family, felt like I was in my Ma's kitchen BSing with my cousins. Next, pizza! OMG! Listen I live in Chicago, this was hard. But let's not exaggerate and say this was the best pizza I had (because you know we do it better in Chicago), BUTTTT I'll say this was the BEST thin crust pizza I ever had. The slices were bigger than most newborn babies, I didn't finish. This was a food challenge I lost. This was the most ma and pa pizzeria I ever been to that backs their slice. Just go, you won't regret it. Ciao. Also I even bought a shirt to brag back at home.
Huge gimmick slices. Great flavor. Awesome place to bring your friends from out of town.Staff is wonderful, with significant real people vibes.Tip: one slice is plenty!
best pizza in the world !!
Awesome pizzeria!!! Super recommended! Thanks Tammy for an excellent service!!!
The pizzas were huge at this place, biggest slice of pizza ive ever seen. But considering it was my first time being at this place i believe the guy who works the register am not sure if thats the owner but he was type rude. As a customer being there for the first time he definately didnt make it feel welcoming , he didnt really help me or my girlfriend out w. Our order , basically we had to figure it out how to order by ourselfs. The menu doesnt have a seperate category for slices , u would have to look on the chalkboard they have thats hanging on the ceiling over the counter. N they're limited on toppings for slices. The service definately couldve been better , but Me n my girlfriend was just all in it for the pizza considering that it was our first time ever seeing a slice so big we were so intrigued by it n really wanted to try, but this would not be my to go spot considering how rude the guy at the register was. N they only take CASH btw !!!! They dont have a sign that says they only take cash so just be aware anybody reading my review to have CASH on hand ! Pizza was good , but service was trash ??
...Benny's is historic and worthy of the utter awe that you will always find yourself in, when Jerseys GRANDEST slice is found before you!
What happened to Benny's?!?! My friends and I have been going here over many years and they never disappoint...until now. This review is solely on Benny's large pizza slices. In the past, Benny's slices were not only bigger than a regular a slice, but were soft, fresh, and cheesey. Unfortunately, it seems that as of very recently, Benny's slices are thin, crispy and hardly any cheese. Also, the slices we ate were burnt. We didn't like them. Not sure if they changed ingredients. If so, it wasn't a great move. Finally, FYI: The price of an individual slice is $4.50.
This place is forever a favorite pizza place of mine in NJ. Legendary. The food is DELICIOUS - everything from pizza, to fries and wings. All types of beers. The place has such a homey feel to it - and you can see it’s been appreciated for many years. The service is exceptional - everyone makes you feel like family. Their regular pies are great and the 32” pie is one for a memorable experience!Just bring cash - they don’t accept cards.