The Railyard Tavern

14-26 Plaza Rd N, Fair Lawn - 07410
167 reviews
Pizza
(201) 773-3372

First time guest and let me tell you this place did not disappoint. Food and service was 10/10. They have an entire GF menu. I have celiac so I asked the server if everything was cooked separately and he said yes! I feel completely fine after eating it. They even offer GF Pizza although, they might be cooked in the same oven as the regular pizzas. ( I don’t know for sure) I ordered the PEI Mussels which were delicious to the point where I asked for a spoon to eat up the delicious broth they were in. For my entree, I ordered the GF Cheese Ravioli with Vodka Sauce, also amazing! I highly recommend and will be referring my friends and family! Looking forward to going back!

Average level bar food, good discount for happy hour, but when I was there (early happy hour) the service staff was sitting at the bar and couldn't see me waving my hand. I had to get up to ask for another beer, more sauce for the wings, etc.I understand it is hard to find good staff, but perhaps some training would help as well because I was the ONLY table there. I was there at an off time so maybe at prime time you would do better.The roast beef sandwich was good, lots of meat, but by default they put it on regular thin white bread which was disappointing. I was expecting a roll at least. No options were given and I didn't realize I needed to make a special request.

The poor quality food at this establishment is only outshined by the inattentive staff. Coupled with the obnoxiously loud music and overpriced entrees, this is not the tavern stop for an enjoyable dining experience.I came here with a friend who ordered the pork chops, specifically asking to serve without mashed potatoes due to dietary restrictions. His pork chops were "killed again". These overdone chops were tasteless and dry alongside a wasted heap of unwanted instant mashed potatoes. I regret trying them to see if they were worth taking home so they wouldn't go to waste... obviously they weren't.I asked for the salmon on the Gluten Free menu.  My plate had VERY dry salmon and heated up frozen spinach.Aside from not taking an order properly, the waiter was largely missing during the meal and impossible to pin down for help.We appreciate the owner's attempt to "make things right" by offering a free dessert, but the disappointing meals didn't give us much hope for anything more than some kind of instant pudding or boxed brownie from the supermarket.

The food here is delicious when made properly. My gluten free pizza was made regular today, second time this has happened. I ordered thru a third party app who refunded me, but I called the restaurant to see where the error was. The restaurant did not see the note that the pizza was gluten free.I have a gluten allergy, so luckily I know what their gluten free crust looks like and could tell right away this was incorrect.Railyard did offer to make me the correct pizza free of charge, but I had just driven there and back and did not want to make the drive again.Just a note for anyone who is gluten free: double check your order at the restaurant before you leave. If they do it right, it’s delicious!

Came here for the first time over a year ago when I started my job in fair lawn. That day I was over the moon with my margarita. It was a perfect balance of tart and sweet. Wings and fries were delightful, definitely hit a craving spot. Another time went with my sister and I ordered their pizza. Another great item to share! But my favorite item has to be their grilled chicken wrap. I've ordered it a few times to go for either lunch or dinner. Not only is it filling, it's also a healthier option. They have a very extensive menu so lots to choose from, it all sounds so appetizing. A great spot to meet up with friends or coworkers.

Very good food. Pizza is killer if you like thin crust. Service is decent ... they need to hire one or two more servers but our dinner did not take too long to come out. Good selection of beers and drinks. Food is made fresh. Second time we've been here. Thumbs up.

Server was excellent. Hero could had been better, no mayo on hero, no mustard and the tomato included in the hero too too fat. More cold cuts in the sandwich for the price.

Just ordered tonight from here. And wow. My fiance is gluten free and u guys crushed it with ur gluten free menu. Soo freaking good. The gluten free peanut butter pie... wow ! Great job. Will be coming in person soon!

Excellent food, one of the best meals out I've had all year. The service could be improved, and it's a bit pricey for the portions, but the food is top notch; will be back again soon.

Great local place with easy parking. The 12” margarita pizza was delicious. Great tasting sauce with a very nice crust. The lobster Mac and cheese was very tasty with just the right amount of flavor. The open sliced steak sandwich was perfectly cooked and lightly seasoned. Great texture and taste. The chicken fingers were absolutely perfect! Not stringy and cooked perfectly. Awesome fries accompanied several dishes. They were perfectly cooked and seasoned. The menu has a great variety including a very nice GF section. Service is very attentive and the atmosphere is relaxing. Priced reasonably.