The food, atmosphere, price and the service. The perfect place for family. We ordered the antipasto salad, large pizza with pepperoni on half the pizza, penne pasta with italian sauage and tarfuto for desert. It was one of the best food I have ever had since I moved here in NJ from Brooklyn 3 years ago. Very, very delicious. The atmosphere here is very relaxing and comfortable. Service was very attentive.This place is a jam. It will be a go to place for our family.
We have been coming here for years. We get the white pizza with sausage, marinara sauce on the side, and calamari. The food is consistently good, as is the service. Cash only.
Ordered a pepperoni pie here and it was great, really good pizza. Walked in and pie was ready in 15 minutes. Orfered a small pie but even so it seemed like a large pie.Place has a number of tables inside for sit down dining. Was impressed at how fast my pizza was made and wasn't that expensive either.Highly recommend getting pizza here!
Very displeased the last couple of times I’ve come here. Not as good as they used to be. This is the second time I’ve walked into the restaurant and the waiter rudely stares and says the restaurant will be closed for 45 min so the kitchen staff can eat. This happened to me TWICE during different hours. It was like we were bothering them by even walking thru the doors. How about a sign outside or lock the doors? The first time this happened to me I sat with my family for 45 min while we watched the whole staff sit at a table and eat at the same time. How do you run a business like that? The staff alone makes me never want to come here again. Not the same. What a shame.
The best pizza in New Jersey! Or maybe even New York. They use quality of ingredients ( like San Mariano tomatoes from Italy)…and the taste will have you wanting more.The place is cash only and they don’t deliver. Very old school, but so worth the trip.The price is great too. We got 1 medium 16inch pie and 1 personal 10 inch pie for $28. Great price.We can’t wait to go back!
The best pizza in New Jersey! Or maybe even New York. They use quality of ingredients ( like San Mariano tomatoes from Italy)…and the taste will have you wanting more.The place is cash only and they don’t deliver. Very old school, but so worth the trip.The price is great too. We got 1 medium 16inch pie and 1 personal 10 inch pie for $28. Great price.We can’t wait to go back!
Excellent pizza. Byob Cash only
One of my favorite pizza spots in Cliffside park. The Margherita pizza is my favorite! Super thin crust with flavorful pizza sauce and generous amount of toppings. Love that they’re baked in a brick oven, gives a nice woody flavor to the crust and pizza as a whole. Love their calamari and they also have amazing salads. Also amazing service feels like home.
The only pizza place that truly makes me happy is Lombardi’s in Soho….. actually ‘was’ I should have said. Since the first time I ate at Brooklyn Pizza I’ve never wanted to drive to the city again to wait for 20-30min and pay X5. Don’t get me wrong Lombardi’s is the still best Pizzeria in NYC for me but here in Edgewater Brooklyn Pizza is the King!
Hands down my favorite pizza in NJ. Every Brooklyn pizza is not equal so I can’t speak for the others, only Edgewater. Super fresh ingredients and quick service every time. Bring cash, no cc.They are associated with the best pizza families in NYC and you’ll know it at the first bite.