Blue Water Seafood

1126 NJ-18, East Brunswick - 08816
235 reviews
Seafood
(732) 967-9220

We have eaten here numerous times over the years and I’m finally giving a review. We started off with the coconut shrimp and clams on the half shell. Both were terrific and the clams were really fresh with some great strong horseradish. Next we both had the spicy buffalo scallop salad, something I’ve enjoyed here since I 1st had it over 15 years ago. The only knock was that it was slightly over dressed with the balsamic dressing. The scallops were cooked perfectly and delicious. For dinner, yes we over ordered which we tend to here, we had the stuffed scallops with a lobster risotto and the Scottish salmon. The salmon was cooked perfectly, moist and fall apart tender with a crispy potato crust. The scallops were cooked perfectly and the risotto was absolutely delicious. Yes we had leftovers to take home, but we can’t help ourselves when ordering here. There’s a reason why we have been patrons for years, the food is not only fresh but cooked perfectly. The service was great and we had no issues at all. We will absolutely continue to go back.

Always wanted to go here as I heard food was excellent, went out for a get together and was very disappointed. Bread was thin salty stale chips, I got the broiled seafood platter, nothing tasted great , and scallops had an ammonia after taste which after googling found out it means they were bad. My friend had mussels in a red sauce with pasta which he commented tasted just like "chef Boyardee" Calamari appetizer was rubbery and tasteless. Staff was very nice and attentive. Apparently I missed the good days of this restaurant and they have since gone down hill.

Started with my server Raquel, sweet girl !Love her attention and good work;Well the restaurant don’t serve drinks so they need to be specific in the website, so you have to bring your own bottle; I did not know that so I went out to get my ….The place was like a Italian grandma house ; lolEvery one speak so loud ?, the food is amazing and good portion…Very fresh, specifically because is seafood and fish ;Reserve because you not going to find a table just appearing there!!!!And EnjoyAlso a valley park, don’t forget to have cash to tip the guys, they are so amazing ❤️???

Food was pretty good and the portions are a decent size. Tuna and lobster were both cooked just right. Service was good as well with the waiter never missing and generally easy to find. The decor (it is a bit too casual) could be improved to better match the restaurant overall and pricing, which is on the higher side. Overall, pretty happy with our dinner at Blue Water Seafood.

Good food, good service. Grilled octopus quantity were so small.

Food wasn’t the best and way overpriced. Would rather red lobster next door. Not a good environment for families

The food here is delicious! The potions are huge compared to many other restaurants. They serve quality seafood in a quaint setting. It’s cozy and clean and a great choice for dinner or any special occasion. I’m looking forward to my next visit.

We had a private party for my daughters baby shower. my wife and I can not thank you enough, blue water and staff!!! the food was delicious, the service was excellent, we were treated like family. thank you for an amazing job. looking forward to having a baby shower soon.

Very mediocre food at best, unprofessional staff, unsanitary restaurant. Not worth the price. My family and I will not be back.

Good food but unsanitary and horrible customer service. There are many ways to handle an issue with a customer’s order but telling the customer to just “pay the bill or the cops will be a called” after they find hair in their food (& while the rest of the table is still eating their meal) is unprofessional and rude.