Nickolas Pizza Restaurant

1820 Lanes Mill Rd, Brick - 08724
140 reviews
Pizza
(732) 458-8523

Normally we really enjoy the pizza here but this time we ordered a chicken bacon ranch pizza to try it out, But I was disappointed. The chicken was too big not diced up like other places, barely any bacon, and barley any cheese no ranch sauce on the pizza. Yet they throw the packets of ranch in the pizza box to drizzle on top. There was a lot of spots on the pizza that was really dry with no cheese or sauce. If you want a really good chicken bacon ranch go to J&G by far way better. They actually baked the ranch into the pizza so it covers the whole pie.We only tried it here since J&G runs out of bacon fast. We really wanted it from them tonight but we couldn’t no bacon?

Just moved to the area about 4 months ago. Had a hard time finding a good pizza place. We originally tried to get a pizza place that would deliver, and they didn't so we went to other places. But after 4 different pizza places that failed to impress my husband decided to check them out and just drive to get it. Well it was well worth the small drive! The pizza was excellent and I can't wait to try other items on the menu as well. My only problem is they don't deliver, however it was well worth the drive.

just bought a house in the area.. originally from New York area.. went through 4 different pizza places looking for the right pie.. nickolas's is my place for now on.. absolutely fantastic pie

Hands down the best pizza around!! You are treated like family once you walk in the door! I recommend Nick's to everyone!

BEST PIZZA IN TOWN. Staff is very friendly. You can tell the owners put so much love into their food and work. check them out!!

had pretty good cheesteak and the pizza was good to would give 5 stars if they delivered

First off to any newer customers; the guy (Nick) that everyone thought was the Gordon Ramsay of Italian food; WRONG. He was an arrogant, nasty, bossy, loud PITA. His failure rate was 100% if you asked for a slice to just barely be warm, like I do. Those instructions get totally disregarded. Not only did he fail to follow instructions but you can guarantee that the slice comes out with the heat & sloppiness of molten lava. So hot one time I took the tiniest bite in my car & scorched my tongue that I threw the pizza out the window at the intersection by 7-11. Plus when you're the only one in there he stares at you, nodding towards me but talking Italian a mile a minute to his right hand man. Super obvious & rude. It was Nick's way or the highway. Loud & obnoxious.Now the new owners are a joy to interact with & the food is great! They pay attention to detail when you ask something as basic as "Just a tiny bit warm for my slice please." I almost slipped up & told them thank god they took over because the last owner was a J.O. But before I did I was told they are related so I just left it alone.This restaurant is 1000x better without loud, grumpy, obnoxious, doesn't follow any instructions Nick. I highly recommend the place now.

Not their best work. 2 pies and both look like someone poured water on them. Very disappointing, they use to produce a much better product.

We love this place the egg, pepper, mushrooms and sausage sandwiches is so tasty!

All I can say is YUM..So happy this family opened up another restaurant..Pizza great..best chicken soup ever..Many tasty dishes made with love.